Solo Star

More information Review scores, Source ...

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[1]
Blender	[3]
Entertainment Weekly	C+[4]
Slant Magazine	[5]

Close

William Ruhlmann of AllMusic awarded the album three out of five stars, writing that executive producer [Mathew] Knowles surrounded Solange with trendy writer-producers including The Underdogs, Platinum Status, Timbaland, The Neptunes, and Rockwilder, as well as guest appearances from B2K and Lil' Romeo. He described the result as a contemporary R&B album filled with big beats, catchy choruses, and gimmicky production effects, but felt that Solange herself was "lost somewhere in the mix," adding that her "thin, undeveloped voice" was easily overwhelmed at times.^[1] Slant Magazine gave the album two out of five stars, criticizing its largely synthetic sound and emphasis on production over songwriting, and commenting that Solange's voice was strikingly similar to Beyoncé's.^[5]

PopMatters found that Solo Star showed Knowles as a promising and vocally mature young artist with flashes of originality, especially on stronger tracks like "Wonderland." However, it criticizes the album for clichéd lyrics, uneven production, unnecessary remixes, and failing to fully establish her identity outside of Beyoncé's shadow.^[6] Writing for Entertainment Weekly, editor Jim Farber argued that while Knowles benefited from her association with her sister, the comparison ultimately hurt her, concluding that Solo Star "fulfills a cynic's worst suspicion: It's a hollow stencil of DC's last work."^[4] Dan Leroy of The Chicago Tribune observed that most of Solo Star leans on "the usual R&B suspects," yielding mixed results. He singled out weaker cuts like "Wonderland" and remarked that "Feelin’ You Pt. 2" treads overly familiar ground. Still, he noted that tracks such as "I Used to" and "Sky Away" reveal genuine potential and gesture toward "higher aspirations," adding that if she continues to build on those strengths, Beyoncé may not remain the Knowles family's only child of destiny.^[7]

The only two singles released from the album, the N.O.R.E.-featured "Feelin' You (Part II)" and the Neptunes-produced "Crush" (also known as "Don't Fight the Feeling"), failed to chart on the Billboard Hot 100. The album is no longer in print and the online music website iTunes does not sell the album. A re-recording of "Crush", with vastly different instrumental and harmonies and featuring Papa Reu, was included on the movie soundtrack for The Fighting Temptations which stars Solange's sister Beyoncé. This re-recording was renamed "Don't Fight the Feeling" to match the movie poster's tagline. The album was promoted with the Solo Star Tour in 2003.

Solo Star was released in December 2002 in Japan, with a United States release following the next month. It underperformed in the United States, debuting and peaking at number 49 on the Billboard 200 and dropping off the chart five weeks after its debut.^[8] The album also reached number 23 on the Top R&B/Hip-Hop Albums.^[9] By May 2008, Solo Star had sold a total of 112,000 copies, according to Nielsen SoundScan.^[10]

Notes

• Tracks 17, 18 and 19 are four seconds of silence each with bonus following.

Sample credits

• "True Love" contains replayed elements from "So Amazing" by Luther Vandross
• "Thinkin' About You" contains replayed elements from "Scooby Doo Where Are You" by Joseph Barbera, William Hanna, and Hoyt Curtin

Solo Star was re-released in November 2006 with a different artwork and track listing. The reissue album contained twelve tracks: seven tracks from 2002 standard release, four remixes and previously unreleased track titled "Bring It on Home". There is a newly recorded version of "Feelin' You" which features American rapper Slim Thug. Both singles from the album were remixed. "Crush" was remixed by Vibelicious. Also, a duet with Beyoncé featuring Da Brat titled "Naïve" was remixed by Maurice Joshua.