| Name of Master |
Year/s as Master |
| Sir John Mason[8] | 1553–1565 |
| Roger Amice | 1566, 1567, 1568 |
| Richard Mayott | 1569, 1570 |
| Thomas Orpwood | 1571, 1604, 1613, 1614 |
| James Fisher | 1572, 1578, 1585 |
| William Braunch | 1573, 1574, 1581, 1593 |
| Thomas Stampe | 1575, 1577 |
| Thomas Smith | 1576, 1582 |
| Thomas Tesdale[8] | 1579 |
| Thomas Mayott | 1580, 1594, 1603, 1627 |
| Paule Orpwood | 1583, 1595 |
| Lionell Bostock | 1584, 1598 |
| John Fisher | 1586 |
| William Kishey | 1587 |
| Anthony Tesdale | 1588, 1607 |
| John Wise | 1580 |
| Richard Tesdale | 1590 |
| William Lee | 1591, 1602, 1619, 1624 |
| William Welling | 1592 |
| Francis Little | 1596, 1597 |
| Robert Payne | 1599, 1621 |
| John Blacknall | 1600 |
| Paule Dayrell | 1601 |
| James Hide | 1605 |
| William Bostock | 1606 |
| Thomas Reade | 1608, 1623, 1632 |
| Lawrence Stevenson | 1609, 1620 |
| John Mayott | 1612, 1615, 1616, 1625, 1633, 1649, 1659 |
| Richard Curtyn | 1617, 1627, 1635[8] |
| Robert Kisbey | 1618 |
| Richard Chickin | 1622 |
| Thomas Clempson | 1626 |
| Edmond Bostock | 1628, 1636 |
| John Fyssher | 1629 |
| John Payne | 1630 |
| Edmund Franklyn | 1631, 1642, 1654 |
| Thomas Wilde | 1637 |
| John Hawes | 1638 |
| William Castell | 1638 |
| Richard Mayott | 1639, 1643 |
| William Payne | 1640 |
| Richard Payne | 1641 |
| Robert Mayott | 1643 |
| Thomas Steed | 1644 |
| John Bolter | 1645, 1656 |
| James Curteyne | 1646, 1657, 1665, 1675, 1684 |
| Thomas Payne | 1647, 1655 |
| Richard Cheyney | 1648 |
| Francis Payne | 1650, 1658, 1668, 1672 |
| Jonathan Hawe | 1651, 1660, 1664, 1671, 1682 |
| Edward Bond | 1652, 1662 |
| William Wells | 1653, 1661 |
| William Cheyney | 1663, 1666 |
| William Weston | 1667 |
| John Payne | 1668, 1677, 1686, 1694 |
| George Winchurst | 1670 |
| Robert Blackaller | 1673, 1678, 1685, 1693, 1709 |
| Robert Morris | 1674, 1679, 1687, 1695 |
| William Cheyney | 1676, 1690 |
| Robert Sellwood | 1680, 1689, 1696, 1703 |
| Richard West | 1681, 1688 |
| Thomas Hulcotts | 1683 |
| James Corderoy | 1691 |
| Thomas Sparks | 1692 |
| Michael Rawlins | 1697, 1705, 1716, 1723 |
| Henry Knapp | 1698, 1708 |
| John Sellwood | 1699, 1707 |
| John Spinage | 1700, 1714 |
| Richard Ely | 1701, 1706, 1715, 1724, 1726, 1729 |
| George Drew | 1702 |
| Robert Mayott | 1704 |
| Thomas King | 1710 |
| William Phillipson | 1711 |
| William Dunn | 1712 |
| Richard Mayott | 1713 |
| John Rawlins | 1717 |
| Anthony Clackson | 1718 |
| Clement Saxton | 1719, 1729 |
| Thomas Prince Sr. | 1720 |
| John Pretty | 1721 |
| Matthew Anderson | 1722, 1739, 1740, 1741, 1752, 1759, 1764 |
| James Saunders | 1725, 1740 |
| William Wells | 1726 |
| Thomas Read | 1727, 1730, 1741 |
|
| Name of Master |
Year/s as Master |
| John Waldron | 1728 |
| William Motley | 1730 |
| Edward Saxton | 1731 |
| Edward Green | 1732, 1743 |
| William Hawkins | 1733, 1744 |
| Edward Spinage | 1734, 1742 |
| William Yateman | 1735, 1745 |
| John Crossley | 1736, 1746 |
| John Knapp | 1737, 1747 |
| John Fludger | 1738, 1748, 1764 |
| Thomas Justice | 1749, 1757, 1761, 1765 |
| John Eldridge | 1750, 1766 |
| Richard Basely | 1751, 1770 |
| Rev. Michael Rawlins | 1753 |
| Edward Baldwin | 1754 |
| Richard Rose | 1755, 1771 |
| George Knapp Sr. | 1756, 1772 |
| Charles Cox | 1757 |
| Henry Harding | 1758 |
| John Bowles | 1760, 1784 |
| John Knapp | 1762 |
| Thomas Prince Jr. | 1763 |
| Joseph Penn | 1767 |
| Robert Crew | 1768 |
| Dudson Rawlins | 1769, 1790 |
| William Bowles | 1776, 1778, 1789 |
| William Eldridge | 1777, 1792 |
| John Payne | 1778 |
| Robert Crew | 1780 |
| James Powell | 1780, 1793 |
| John Harding | 1781 |
| John Bedwell | 1782, 1794 |
| Edward Child | 1783, 1795, 1804, 1814 |
| Samuell Sellwood | 1785, 1797, 1805, 1816 |
| William Allder | 1786, 1798, 1806 |
| George Hawkins | 1787, 1788 |
| James Penn | 1791 |
| James Smallbone | 1793 |
| Thomas Prince III | 1796, 1808, 1812 |
| Henry Knapp Sr. | 1799, 1811 |
| John Eldridge | 1800 |
| Thomas Knight | 1801, 1814, 1815, 1826, 1827 |
| Benjamin Morland | 1802 |
| John Gallaway | 1803 |
| John Francis Spenlove | 1807, 1820, 1828 |
| Thomas Baker | 1809, 1819, 1831 |
| James Cole | 1810, 1821, 1832 |
| Richard Bradfield | 1813, 1824 |
| Samuel Cripps | 1817 |
| Henry Knapp Jr. | 1818, 1834 |
| Thomas West | 1822 |
| Thomas Curtis | 1823, 1835 |
| Charles King | 1825, 1837 |
| William Church | 1826 |
| John Vindin Collingwood | 1829, 1839 |
| William Strange | 1830 |
| William Doe Belcher | 1833, 1842, 1843, 1854 |
| George Bowes Morland | 1836, 1844, 1866, 1867 |
| Daniel Godfrey | 1838, 1847, 1855, 1859, 1868 |
| Richard Badcock | 1840, 1864 |
| Benjamin Collingwood | 1841 |
| John Hyde | 1845, 1850, 1856, 1861, 1870 |
| John Tomkins | 1846, 1851, 1857 |
| William Belcher | 1848, 1853, 1862 |
| Thomas Hedges Graham | 1849, 1860, 1869 |
| Edwin James Trendell | 1852, 1863 |
| William Pemberton | 1858, 1865 |
| John Creemer Clarke | c.1890 |
| Arthur Edwin Preston | 1929[8] |
| John Holden Hooke | 1959 |
| Herbert George Mullard | 1962–76 |
| Douglas Arthur Kitto | |
| Dr Jack Cherry | 1984–85 |
| Ernest William Johnston Nicholson | 1985–86 |
| William James Howard Liversidge | 1986, 1987 |
| Norman John Holmes | |
| David Roger Barrett | |
| Michael William Matthews | 1997 |
| Thomas Chamberlain | 1998 |
| Helen Mary Ronaldson | 2003[9] |
| Geoffrey Robert Morris | 2008 |
| Robert Farrant | 2009 |
| Tom Ayling | 2018–present [10] |
|