Everybody's Girl (film)

Florence and her roommate, Ella, work trimming hats, and live in a flat on Brick Dust Row. Because of his stinginess, their rich landlord has taken away the girls' parlor in order to rent it out to a business. Due to this fact, the two women could not entertain young men in their apartment, so they would meet them in the park. During one of their outings, they go on the Staten Island Ferry, where they meet Blinker, a rich man who has taken the ferry to get away from his regular group of friends. Florence and Blinker hit it off, and she agrees to meet him again.

One night, a local tough, Bill gets into a fight where he uses his gun to get out of it. Fleeing from the police, he ends up in Florence and Ella's room, although Ella is out. At first, Florence is quite scared, but Bill calms her and eventually earns her trust. When the police do get around to searching Florence's building, she tells them that Bill is her brother and he has been with her all evening, earning his gratitude. Bill becomes the girls' protector, looking after them to make sure nothing bad happens to them. Additionally, he begins to have an emotional relationship with Ella.

When Florence goes to meet Blinker again on the ferry, Bill is following, to keep watch over her. While on the ferry, Blinker presses Florence to know more about her past. She admits to meeting men in the park, which shocks Blinker's sensibilities. He is about to let her down easy, when the boat catches fire. Florence jumps overboard, and Blinker dives in after her to save her. They are both in danger of drowning when Bill arrives and saves the both of them. When they get to shore, Blinker leaves, and Florence is distraught, feeling that she has lost the only man she has ever loved. Bill goes to Blinker, and explains what a true and honest woman she is. He convinces Blinker, who reunites with Florence.