God's Pottery

The duo often would just mess around and make up fake bands.^[3] While Hall was on vacation he came up with a Christian band idea and wrote some funny song titles.^[3] Before they knew it they were writing lyrics and began performing in rooms in downtown NYC.^[3]

Initially the idea was to goof around, but quickly comedians like Eugene Mirman and the Upright Citizens Brigade invited the duo to perform on their shows.^[3]

They made the act into an hour long show and traveled to Edinburgh Festival Fringe and signed with Mirman's manager.^[3]

The angle comedically was it was ludicrous, but there was no winking. We were always deeply in character. And we always took it seriously.
— Krister Johnson^[3]

God's Pottery appeared on the sixth season of the NBC reality show Last Comic Standing. They were selected as semi-finalists in the New York City audition, then selected as finalists after a performance in Las Vegas, Nevada. They were eliminated along with Esther Ku in the first head-to-head elimination round on Episode 7, finishing in 12th place.^[3]

The duo released an EP from Comedy Central Records entitled Live at Comix in December 2007.

They also wrote the book What Would God's Pottery Do.