Love the One You're With

Stills wrote the song after being inspired by the tag line — "If you can't be with the one you love, love the one you're with" which was a frequent remark by musician Billy Preston. Stills explained in 1991: "This song has been very good to me. The title came from a party with Billy Preston. The I asked him if I could pinch this line he had, and he said, 'Sure.' So I took the phrase and wrote a song around it. It's a good times song, just a bit of fun. My favorite part is the steel drums. I played them before a little bit but I just kept diddling around till I found the right notes."^[4] Billy Preston may have been familiar with the song "When I'm Not Near the Girl I Love" from the 1947 musical Finian's Rainbow which has the line "When I can't be with the girl I love, I love the girl I'm with".^[5] Like the majority of the album, Stills recorded the song over the previous summer.^[6] Former CSNY bandmate Graham Nash recalled in his book Wild Tales: "Stephen called and said, 'You remember that song of mine, "Love the One You’re With," that I cut in London? Well, I've brought the track back and we're in Wally Heider's with it. I need voices for the choruses. Any chance you and David would come down?'".^[6]

Cash Box said that Stills's "unique melodic work, the harmonies and a booming rhythm track make this a bright attraction for top forty as well as FM playlists."^[7] Record World said that "Stills shines with the help of some fine background singers and his vocal style is exemplary, as usual. The song's universal message is put across with a bright, yet driving, delivery."^[8]

• Stephen Stills : Vocals, guitar, organ, steel drums, percussion
• Calvin "Fuzzy" Samuel : Bass guitar
• Jeff Whittaker – congas
• Rita Coolidge, David Crosby, Priscilla Jones, Graham Nash, John Sebastian – backing vocals

Several acts have since recorded the song, most notably, in 1971, the Isley Brothers as the lead single from their ninth studio album Givin' It Back, whose unique gospel-driven rendering of the song sent it to the charts again reaching number three R&B and number 18 pop, giving the group their fifth US top 40 pop single.^[21] It also reached number 10 on the US Cash Box chart. On the Canadian charts, their version reached No. 41.^[22]

British pop group Bucks Fizz covered the song as the fourth and penultimate single of their 1986 album Writing on the Wall. The single, released in August, was the follow-up to the group's comeback top ten hit "New Beginning (Mamba Seyra)" and was seen as a make or break release. Ultimately the song peaked at a low No.47 in the UK Singles Chart during a three-week run.^[23] In a review, music magazine Number One said that the song lacked bass and sounded rather "tinny" but predicted that it would be a hit.^[24]

Bucks Fizz member Mike Nolan puts the song's chart failure down to the decision to showcase other male member Bobby G as the lead singer. Their previous single had featured all the group equally and was a hit, while earlier flops had featured Bobby G on lead and this was a return to that format.^[25] A promotional video for the song was filmed featuring the group performing the song in a blue-toned studio accompanied by backing musicians.^[26] The single was released on 7" and 12" on Polydor Records with an extended mix on the latter, the B-side was a Bobby G composition, "Too Hard".^[27] Also included on the 12" was an extended mix of earlier single "I Hear Talk". A second 12" single was released featuring a dance edit of "Love the One You're With", backed by another alternate mix of "I Hear Talk".^[28]

Australian pop group the Chantoozies released a version in February 1991. The song was the third and final single from the group's second studio album, Gild the Lily (1991). The song peaked at number 21 on the Australian charts.^[29]

Charts

More information Chart (1991), Peak position ...

Chart (1991)	Peak position
Australia (ARIA)[30]	21

Close

American singer-songwriter Luther Vandross released a version of the song on his ninth album, Songs (1994). It peaked within the top 30 of the US Billboard Hot R&B Singles chart, reached number 33 on the Billboard Hot Adult Contemporary Tracks chart, and earned Vandross a 1995 Grammy nomination for Best Male Pop Vocal Performance.^[32] The single was accompanied by a black-and-white music video.

Critical reception

M.R. Martinez from Cash Box described "Love the One You’re With" as "an optimistic celebration of love and music as Vandross is backed by an all-star choir that includes Lisa Fischer, Tawatha Gee, Jim Gilstrap and others."^[33] Fell and Rufer from the Gavin Report wrote, "This 25-year-old Stephen Stills song was urbanized before by the Isley Brothers, but Luther turns it into a gospel hoot complete with the original Hammond organ effects from Stills's take. This is the song that garnered Vandross a Grammy nomination even before it was released as a single."^[34]

Dennis Hunt from Los Angeles Times felt Vandross "gives a leaden feel to the normally joyous 'Love the One You're With', undercutting a breezy, gospel-style arrangement."^[35] Pan-European magazine Music & Media commented, "Hailed the King of silky ballads, Luther also knows how to speed it up. In a New Orleans way, and challenged by a gospel group, this [...] cover shows him at his toughest."^[36] Alan Jones from Music Week complimented it as "a nice remake".^[37]

Charts

More information Chart (1994–1995), Peak position ...

Chart (1994–1995)	Peak position
Australia (ARIA)[38]	56
Canada Top Singles (RPM)[39]	40
Europe (European Hit Radio)[40]	26
Iceland (Íslenski Listinn Topp 40)[41]	38
Scotland (OCC)[42]	41
UK Singles (OCC)[43]	31
UK Airplay (Music Week)[44]	8
US Billboard Hot 100[45]	95

Close

• Gino Soccio reached number 79 in Canada with a 1988 recording of the song.^[46]
• Dutch duo Pep & Rash sampled this song in their song of the same name in 2016, which was a minor hit at Number 79 in French Belgium.^[47][48]

In 2012, the song was featured in Ridley Scott's science fiction movie Prometheus. Idris Elba, playing Janek, sings a short phrase from the song after claiming his squeezebox once belonged to Stephen Stills.^[49]

In 2022 the song featured in the season finale of BBC series Blue Lights.^{[citation needed]}