Memorial University of Newfoundland Students' Union

Fall Orientation Concert 2009

In the fall of 2009, MUNSU lost over $100,000 on their annual fall orientation concert. The union brought rapper Snoop Dogg to St. John's Mile One Stadium on September 12, 2009 at a cost of $300,000; however, they only sold 2,500 out of a possible 6,200 seats. Critics claim that the union conducted no market research or survey of the student population to see if the rap act would appeal to them. Several MUNSU directors and members of the student activities committee also came forward saying that the decision was made without their approval or notification.^[13][14][15]

Copygate/Better Side notebook scandal

In fall of 2009, in their attempts for environmental sustainability and reducing paper use, staff of the MUNSU Copy Centre reused student loan application forms and other government documents that people had faxed, instead of shredding them. The campaign was meant to only reuse paper that did not contain sensitive information, but no procedure was developed. The Government of NL and MUN Chief Information Office Opened an investigation in fall of 2009 into the Better Side Notebook Scandal, referred to as "Copygate", which led to MUNSU discontinuing the Better Side Notebooks. No effort was ever made to find a way to reuse paper and the idea died instead.^[16]

Credit card scandal and monetary scandals

In the 2009-2010 academic year, several executive members of the union were accused in an anonymous letter of abusing their union credit cards for personal expenses. A committee was formed to investigate both the source of the letter, its validity, and the executive credit card records. The executive director of student life with the Union resigned in the heat of the controversy.^[17][18][19]

Prolonged strike of City Transit

In the fall semester of 2010, Metrobus, the city transit on which the vast majority of commuting students rely, ceased service due to a strike.^[20] MUNSU, working closely with related unions, became internally aware of the intended strike in advance and made no move to aid students, whose lives, studies, and careers would be affected by this. Rather, members of MUNSU acting without quorum announced that the union supported the striking bus drivers, picketing alongside and giving the impression that their major service consumers supported them—in effect, prolonging the strike for the remainder of the semester.^[21][22]

Claiming car payments as executive expenses

In winter of 2010, it was revealed that MUNSU executive pre 2010 had claimed car repair payments and the like as executive expenses hidden within their budgets. This was able to occur because MUNSU’s budget simply lists the total aggregate amount spent on each service (Breezeway, Copy Centre) and Misc items, but there is no line item list of all expenses made publicly available unless you request to see it in the MUNSU office."^[18]

Parking

In 2010, the university closed the largest student parking area for development into a new lot for the Health Sciences Centre. Students were allowed to use a temporary lot on the construction site of a new residence yet to be built, however due to the commencement of construction as of the 23rd of July that lot is also closed.^[23] This leaves the entire university student body with less than 250 parking places. Critics are bashing both the University and the student union for failing to plan and make arrangements for student parking since the developments were announced several years in advance. When questioned about the issue both the university and the union have stated that parking is not in their list of priorities as it does not meet their environmental policy. Before the closure of the student parking lot in early 2010 the university sustainability office sent out a survey asking students leading questions, making them chose between their interests in the environment and their desire for adequate parking. The survey stated the results would be published on the sustainability website; however, as of August 2010, the results are still unpublished. Pressure is still being applied on the union by several groups of students to do something on the issue.

Attempted closure of the Disability Information and Support Centre

In the winter of 2012, the Disability Information and Support Centre, an autonomous organization predating MUNSU underwent organizational restructuring. This process was initiated by a vote of non-confidence against the then president of the organization. By constitutional process, a by-election was to be called to fill the vacancy and move forward from the turbulence. However, MUNSU representatives attempted to claim ownership of the centre by manually changing the door handle to a new key.^[24] In the following 8 month legal battle during which several MPs and MHAs involved themselves to aid the centre MUNSU began compiling a list of members of the centre, effectively creating a census of the minority. Refusing to submit to external control from MUNSU the organization internally orchestrated a new election and found a new president whose first act was to document the actions taken against the centre, the relationship between the two organizations, and form a legal snapshot to be sent to local Members of Parliament. Immediately following this the Students Union ceased their antagonism of the centre and their Director of Operations took a year-long sabbatical before resigning.

Centres' Board of Directors reformation

The Centres' Board of Directors is mandated by MUNSU's 2007 Bylaws to meet twice per semester and charged with maintaining the safe operation of the centres. It was designed as a way to bridge the many separate organizations, by giving each two seats on the board. In total the seven centres and MUNSU occupied 16 seats. However, MUNSU left the board unattended. The centres internally appointed their members as procedure dictated and continued to work towards their objectives. In the Fall of 2013 MUNSU became aware that the Board was continuing to operate without them and began immediately editing their bylaws to consolidate authority. Their edits reduced the seats per centre from two seats to one, while increasing MUNSU seats from two to ten. MUNSU edits to their bylaws also posits the MUNSU Resource Coordinator as the Chairperson of the Board, contrary to how the board normally operated.^[25]

Not-for-Profit debate

MUNSU, only registered part way as a not-for-profit, had, from 1999 until late 2013, been getting the best both worlds. While effectively a for-profit business, they attempted to make their on-campus bar a success while refusing to pay property taxes. In a case of the Supreme Court of Newfoundland and Labrador, it was MUNSU's position that the Breezeway was an educational facility that should be exempt from paying property taxes along with other already exempt services such as the Attic, a convenience store with fax-room capabilities on campus.^[26] MUNSU's original lease agreement with the university cost only $1. The court ruled that while MUN is an educational institution, MUNSU is not and as such MUNSU has been fined $360,000.^[27]

• Official website
• ^[1]