O'Flaherty died on 27 September 2016; his death was announced by Noel Thompson on Good Morning Ulster.[1][2][5][6] Speaking after his death was announced, Peter Johnston, the Controller of BBC Northern Ireland, said that "We were all deeply saddened to hear of the death of Paddy, who for many years was a well-known face and voice across our airwaves and television screens." [1][4][6] Northern Ireland First Minister Arlene Foster said that she was "really sorry to hear about Paddy's death. Such a gentle person", whilst deputy First Minister Martin McGuinness said that O'Flaherty was "a wonderful broadcaster, fiddler and like myself, a fly fisherman".[4] Séamus Dooley from the National Union of Journalists said that O'Flaherty was "the embodiment of all that is best in public service broadcasting".[1][4] He was remembered at the 2016 Phonographic Performance Ireland Radio Awards along with Terry Wogan.[7] His funeral was held at St Gerard's Church in Belfast, and was attended by 300 people.[8] O'Flaherty's wife Brenda died in 2003, and he is survived by his two children.[3]