| Discussion Topic | Replies (estimated) | Archive Link |
|---|
| I don't understand | 2 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 1#I don't understand |
| Civilizations in human history | 4 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 2#Civilizations in human history |
| Peaceful, or civil interaction | 2 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 2#Peaceful, or civil interaction |
| Racist/ethnocentric | 10 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 2#Racist/ethnocentric |
| Oops - what happened to the other languages bit | 2 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 2#Oops - what happened to the other languages bit |
| Proposed move: from Civilization to Civilisation | 24 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 3#Proposed move: from Civilization to Civilisation |
| Comments left at top of page | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 4#Comments left at top of page |
| Roman Definition | 2 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 4#Roman Definition |
| Fertile Crescent includes Egypt | 5 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 4#Fertile Crescent includes Egypt |
| Improvement drive | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 4#Improvement drive |
| Hyperbole in the Indian Civilization section, where are the sources? | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 4#Hyperbole in the Indian Civilization section, where are the sources? |
| Ruins in the Gulf of Cambay | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 4#Ruins in the Gulf of Cambay |
| Dates on Civilization | 2 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 4#Dates on Civilization |
| Dates on Civilization | 9 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 4#Dates on Civilization 2 |
| Confusion | 16 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Confusion |
| Civilization and Socialism | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 4#Civilization and Socialism |
| "Complexity" | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#"Complexity" |
| Caral and Olmec - which counts as first 'New World' civilization? | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Caral and Olmec - which counts as first 'New World' civilization? |
| Missing | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 4#Missing |
| Egyptians on Silk Road? | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 4#Egyptians on Silk Road? |
| Gojoseon | 2 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Gojoseon |
| Editing of "Primitive" | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Editing of "Primitive" |
| Discussion on the "end of civilization" | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Discussion on the "end of civilization" |
| Korea (Gojoseon) date of 2333BC is disputed | 9 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Korea (Gojoseon) date of 2333BC is disputed |
| Neolithic cultures | 5 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Neolithic cultures |
| On the Fall of Civilisations | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#On the Fall of Civilisations |
| POV statements? | 11 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#POV statements? |
| The intro | 6 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#The intro |
| Atlantis Mu and Lemuria | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Atlantis Mu and Lemuria |
| Art, philosophy, science | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Art, philosophy, science |
| Human society as a whole | 2 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Human society as a whole |
| Section on Hebrew Civilisation | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Section on Hebrew Civilisation |
| Out of India Theory | 2 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Out of India Theory |
| Why is this article limited to Early Civilisations | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Why is this article limited to Early Civilisations |
| China 2200 BC-present? | 5 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#China 2200 BC-present? |
| Concern | 4 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Concern |
| Dubious | 4 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Dubious |
| Mehrgahr | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Mehrgahr |
| Vedic civilization | 3 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Vedic civilization |
| Han Dinasty claimed Koguryo as their part!!! | 2 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Han Dinasty claimed Koguryo as their part!!! |
| Civilisations through to the present | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Civilisations through to the present |
| Cut back on the equivocal definitions | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Cut back on the equivocal definitions |
| New lead section? | 4 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#New lead section? |
| What's happened to our images? | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#What's happened to our images? |
| Deletion of attack on Ward Perkins | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Deletion of attack on Ward Perkins |
| Atlantis | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Atlantis |
| Indus Valley civilisation needs editing | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 5#Indus Valley civilisation needs editing |
| Civilization | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Civilization |
| anti european bias | 6 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#anti european bias |
| Archive | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Archive |
| Are towns necessary for "Civilisation" ? | 2 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Are towns necessary for "Civilisation" ? |
| Definitions | 5 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Definitions |
| Possible Vandalism | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Possible Vandalism |
| Format | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Format |
| Replacing a Copyvio Pic | 3 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Replacing a Copyvio Pic |
| Ismael book/writer | 5 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Ismael book/writer |
| Last two paragraphs of the intro | 3 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Last two paragraphs of the intro |
| The Great Flood | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#The Great Flood |
| Are We Smarter than Yeast? | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Are We Smarter than Yeast? |
| Another suggestion... | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Another suggestion... |
| Civilizations of the XXI Century Map | 13 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Civilizations of the XXI Century Map |
| Jiroft | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Jiroft |
| Some corrections | 2 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Some corrections |
| Dates of the Axial Age? | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Dates of the Axial Age? |
| Controversy Over the Use of the World 'Civilization' | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Controversy Over the Use of the World 'Civilization' |
| Africa? | 2 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Africa? |
| Simple Definition of Civilization | 2 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Simple Definition of Civilization |
| Vere Gordon Childe is unreliable | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Vere Gordon Childe is unreliable |
| Automate archiving? | 2 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Automate archiving? |
| Cringeworthy | 4 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Cringeworthy |
| Removed "Georgian and Armenian civilisation" from European category | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Removed "Georgian and Armenian civilisation" from European category |
| Deleted reference to "Red Indians" in the definition | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Deleted reference to "Red Indians" in the definition |
| New Beginning | 2 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#New Beginning |
| Merger with World Civilisations and Ancient Civilizations | 6 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Merger with World Civilisations and Ancient Civilizations |
| Amerocentrism | 6 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Amerocentrism |
| Is the multiple issues tag still needed? | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Is the multiple issues tag still needed? |
| Map | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Map |
| Maiming | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Maiming |
| Very confusing | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Very confusing |
| Dispute regarding lead image(s) | 8 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Dispute regarding lead image(s) |
| File:Sumerian 26th c Adab.jpg Nominated for speedy Deletion | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#File:Sumerian 26th c Adab.jpg Nominated for speedy Deletion |
| Connection with faith | 3 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Connection with faith |
| confusing image | 2 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#confusing image |
| lead fails to define a topic | 29 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#lead fails to define a topic |
| The main problem this article has to struggle with | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#The main problem this article has to struggle with |
| Main Image | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Main Image |
| Neolithic in lede | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Neolithic in lede |
| Undue discussion of "Axial age"? | 27 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Undue discussion of "Axial age"? |
| Structure of the article | 11 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Structure of the article |
| Correcting errors | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Correcting errors |
| Kush, Axum and Nok | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Kush, Axum and Nok |
| CivilizationL improvements! | 23 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#CivilizationL improvements! |
| Severe problems in the Origins of Civilization section | 3 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Severe problems in the Origins of Civilization section |
| Problems with lead | 3 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Problems with lead |
| The role of human sacrifice | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#The role of human sacrifice |
| BC map? | 2 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#BC map? |
| External links modified | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#External links modified |
| External links modified | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#External links modified 2 |
| Nomination of Portal:Civilizations for deletion | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Nomination of Portal:Civilizations for deletion |
| Considering removing image of Temple of Bacchus from "Examples of civilization" | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Considering removing image of Temple of Bacchus from "Examples of civilization" |
| This article is terrible | 2 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#This article is terrible |
| "Dawn of civilization" listed at Redirects for discussion | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#"Dawn of civilization" listed at Redirects for discussion |
| Iran the first.... | 3 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Iran the first.... |
| Absence of the Americas | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Absence of the Americas |
| eurocentric views??? | 10 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#eurocentric views??? |
| Neutral POV problem | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Neutral POV problem |
| Criticism section | 4 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Criticism section |
| Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment |
| Weird definition | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Weird definition |
| Who is referring to Athens as the birthplace of democracy? | 4 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Who is referring to Athens as the birthplace of democracy? |
| Dubious concept and reference | 1 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Dubious concept and reference |
| Terms under section History being applied inappropriately | 36 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 7#Terms under section History being applied inappropriately |
| Huntington's "future" | 6 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Huntington's "future" |
| Widely referred to by many? | 10 | Talk:Civilization/Archive 6#Widely referred to by many? |
| "Urban civilisation" needs article | 2 | Talk:Civilization#"Urban civilisation" needs article |
| Criticisms of the concept? | 1 | Talk:Civilization#Criticisms of the concept? |