| Discussion Topic | Replies (estimated) | Archive Link |
|---|
| Moved from Talk:emdrive | 31 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Moved from Talk:emdrive |
| Initial comments | 9 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Initial comments |
| Merge discussion | 5 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Merge discussion |
| Worst case | 3 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Worst case |
| Answering the momentum question | 5 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Answering the momentum question |
| Off topic cite removed | 1 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Off topic cite removed |
| Factual Accuracy tag | 5 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Factual Accuracy tag |
| Theory | 2 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Theory |
| Rockets | 3 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Rockets |
| Perpetual Motion | 3 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Perpetual Motion |
| Realistic Comments | 1 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Realistic Comments |
| Excellent Article | 2 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Excellent Article |
| New Scientist reaction | 1 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#New Scientist reaction |
| Neutral Point of View | 9 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Neutral Point of View |
| A possible explanation | 3 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#A possible explanation |
| Just Suppose | 1 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Just Suppose |
| Cut the Gordian Knot | 1 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Cut the Gordian Knot |
| My two cents | 6 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#My two cents |
| EM Drive | 5 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#EM Drive |
| I've added a hoax tag. | 2 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#I've added a hoax tag. |
| This article is a train wreck | 1 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#This article is a train wreck |
| How many times can we say HOAX | 2 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#How many times can we say HOAX |
| Analysis | 7 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#Analysis |
| Flight International | 1 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Flight International |
| Presentation at Space '08 | 10 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Presentation at Space '08 |
| Biefield-Brown effect | 4 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Biefield-Brown effect |
| Northwestern Polytechnical University | 6 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Northwestern Polytechnical University |
| Requested rename | 5 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Requested rename |
| Automate archiving? | 2 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Automate archiving? |
| Dr. John Costella | 3 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Dr. John Costella |
| BUILD IT | 2 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#BUILD IT |
| Implications of EM-drive success or failure | 1 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Implications of EM-drive success or failure |
| Bloody biased article | 4 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Bloody biased article |
| Stationary? | 2 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#Stationary? |
| July 2014: Major expansion of the article | 4 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#July 2014: Major expansion of the article |
| Group velocity | 5 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#Group velocity |
| Velocity dependence | 6 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 1#Velocity dependence |
| An "open system" from which no energy or matter leaves or enters | 8 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#An "open system" from which no energy or matter leaves or enters |
| NASA testing | 13 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#NASA testing |
| 3kN is not equivalent to 3 tonnes (assuming Earth) | 2 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#3kN is not equivalent to 3 tonnes (assuming Earth) |
| Misleading analysis | 4 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#Misleading analysis |
| Fringe theories | 16 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#Fringe theories |
| Tinkerer? | 3 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#Tinkerer? |
| Categories | 1 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#Categories |
| Links to More Info (Cannae & EmDrive) | 2 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#Links to More Info (Cannae & EmDrive) |
| Criticism section: Neutral point of view, due weight and original research | 9 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#Criticism section: Neutral point of view, due weight and original research |
| Self-published sources | 18 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#Self-published sources |
| Original research | 3 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#Original research |
| Skeptic Weighs In | 2 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#Skeptic Weighs In |
| Requested move | 18 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#Requested move |
| New sources | 5 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#New sources |
| Pseudophysics | 44 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#Pseudophysics |
| criticism section | 5 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#criticism section |
| Diagram? | 1 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#Diagram? |
| Peculiar citation | 8 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#Peculiar citation |
| Colin Johnston | 11 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#Colin Johnston |
| Minotti's paper | 1 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#Minotti's paper |
| Dielectric section | 4 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#Dielectric section |
| Ablation | 11 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#Ablation |
| Electric charge | 1 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 2#Electric charge |
| No energy leaves the device, but it requires an energy source? How does that work? | 8 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#No energy leaves the device, but it requires an energy source? How does that work? |
| Cannae drive | 19 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#Cannae drive |
| Cannae drive 2011 results | 1 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#Cannae drive 2011 results |
| "Theory" | 2 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#"Theory" |
| Adapt the EM drive to drive a electrical generator | 21 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 4#Adapt the EM drive to drive a electrical generator |
| Could someone institute automated archiving? | 2 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#Could someone institute automated archiving? |
| Suggested explanation | 5 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#Suggested explanation |
| Possible way | 2 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#Possible way |
| Warp drive? | 4 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#Warp drive? |
| Semi-protected edit request on 3 May 2015 | 2 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#Semi-protected edit request on 3 May 2015 |
| I'm been reverted by the user GliderMaven | 20 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#I'm been reverted by the user GliderMaven |
| Notes On EmDrive Controversy | 1 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#Notes On EmDrive Controversy |
| Static Thrust | 3 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#Static Thrust |
| Cleanup | 3 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#Cleanup |
| EmDrive -> RF resonant cavity thruster -> Asymmetric cavity drive? | 5 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 4#EmDrive -> RF resonant cavity thruster -> Asymmetric cavity drive? |
| Criticism | 8 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#Criticism |
| Intro, and claims | 6 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 4#Intro, and claims |
| Listed as violating conservation of momentum | 23 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 4#Listed as violating conservation of momentum |
| Controversy section surely needs rewrite | 7 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 6#Controversy section surely needs rewrite |
| Queries | 2 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 4#Queries |
| Peer review? | 3 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 4#Peer review? |
| Notes On Edit Of The History Section | 1 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 4#Notes On Edit Of The History Section |
| not designed to produce thrust | 3 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 4#not designed to produce thrust |
| Lede is confusing | 14 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 4#Lede is confusing |
| Pseudophysics link, and proposed major rewrite by KRAPENHOEFFER | 4 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 4#Pseudophysics link, and proposed major rewrite by KRAPENHOEFFER |
| Requested move 8 November 2015 | 7 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 4#Requested move 8 November 2015 |
| Removed 'too technical' warning | 1 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 4#Removed 'too technical' warning |
| Added NPOV tag; could use rewrite | 25 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 4#Added NPOV tag; could use rewrite |
| Some new sources | 1 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 4#Some new sources |
| end sentence in the lede is a bit vague | 1 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 4#end sentence in the lede is a bit vague |
| Marketing claim in lede | 11 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 4#Marketing claim in lede |
| Possible new hypothesis | 16 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#Possible new hypothesis |
| Quit saying this drive violates Newton's 3rd law! | 3 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#Quit saying this drive violates Newton's 3rd law! |
| I Call Bullshit! | 4 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#I Call Bullshit! |
| Hype over "propellant-less" | 10 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 3#Hype over "propellant-less" |
| New Peer-reviewed paper in AIP Advances claims to explain the exhaust of the Emdrive | 46 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 6#New Peer-reviewed paper in AIP Advances claims to explain the exhaust of the Emdrive |
| Pseudoscience | 18 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 4#Pseudoscience |
| Eagleworks Passed Peer Review, article needs re-writing to trim fringe theories and incorporate this into article. | 8 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 5#Eagleworks Passed Peer Review, article needs re-writing to trim fringe theories and incorporate this into article. |
| Another null result: Martin Tajmar and G. Fiedler | 5 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 5#Another null result: Martin Tajmar and G. Fiedler |
| Rewriting the lede | 6 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 5#Rewriting the lede |
| Apparently Fetta is going to send one to space on a cubesat | 4 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 5#Apparently Fetta is going to send one to space on a cubesat |
| Overall update | 3 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 5#Overall update |
| Clarifying how this differs from other EM thrusters | 2 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 6#Clarifying how this differs from other EM thrusters |
| Significant Thrust | 5 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 5#Significant Thrust |
| A few new sources. | 3 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 5#A few new sources. |
| Circular reference | 2 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 5#Circular reference |
| Magnetic Propulsion | 5 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 5#Magnetic Propulsion |
| Peer-reviewed NASA report in AIAA. And reviews of it | 3 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 5#Peer-reviewed NASA report in AIAA. And reviews of it |
| Section: The first Peer-reviewed EM Drive paper | 24 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 5#Section: The first Peer-reviewed EM Drive paper |
| Section: Zero-point field | 24 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 5#Section: Zero-point field |
| "EmDrive" name | 3 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 7#"EmDrive" name |
| Theoretical work continuously suppressed | 17 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 6#Theoretical work continuously suppressed |
| Disruptive editing | 25 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 7#Disruptive editing |
| Scientific consensus is against EmDrive | 32 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 6#Scientific consensus is against EmDrive |
| Photon Leakage and undue weight | 26 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 7#Photon Leakage and undue weight |
| Creating/Destroying energy via thrusters of this nature | 9 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 7#Creating/Destroying energy via thrusters of this nature |
| Clarifying CAST statement | 5 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 7#Clarifying CAST statement |
| Removed | 4 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 7#Removed |
| IBT as questionable source | 21 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 7#IBT as questionable source |
| One more "valid" (at this point) hypothesis of method of action | 3 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 7#One more "valid" (at this point) hypothesis of method of action |
| Cleaned up device structure | 22 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 7#Cleaned up device structure |
| Resonant cavities to test Lorentz invariance | 16 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 7#Resonant cavities to test Lorentz invariance |
| Original research | 14 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 7#Original research |
| Cannae pun | 1 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 7#Cannae pun |
| No Way! NO! | 10 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 8#No Way! NO! |
| Reset | 3 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 7#Reset |
| Scientific focus | 35 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 8#Scientific focus |
| New conference note by Tajmar et al | 3 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 8#New conference note by Tajmar et al |
| RfC: Should the EmDrive be labeled as Pseudoscience? | 89 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 8#RfC: Should the EmDrive be labeled as Pseudoscience? |
| Photon momentum | 3 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 8#Photon momentum |
| Em engine listed at Redirects for discussion | 1 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 8#Em engine listed at Redirects for discussion |
| Pseudoscience | 6 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 8#Pseudoscience |
| Epistemology | 28 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 8#Epistemology |
| Clarifying vagueness and overwhelming negative results | 3 | Talk:EmDrive#Clarifying vagueness and overwhelming negative results |
| The device could operate for only a few dozen seconds before the magnetron failed, due to overheating. | 2 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 8#The device could operate for only a few dozen seconds before the magnetron failed, due to overheating. |
| Requested move 12 September 2020 | 4 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 8#Requested move 12 September 2020 |
| Requested move 1 April 2021 | 4 | Talk:EmDrive/Archive 9#Requested move 1 April 2021 |
| Removal of content connected with Shawyer | 5 | Talk:EmDrive#Removal of content connected with Shawyer |
| Comparison | 1 | Talk:EmDrive#Comparison |
| Proposal for New Wikipedia Section | 2 | Talk:EmDrive#Proposal for New Wikipedia Section |