| Discussion Topic | Replies (estimated) | Archive Link |
|---|
| Merge proposal | 16 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Merge proposal |
| New data | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#New data |
| States with limited recognition | 6 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#States with limited recognition |
| France | 4 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#France |
| sort by column is wrong | 7 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#sort by column is wrong |
| Greenland | 8 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Greenland |
| Table of the countries | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Table of the countries |
| Percent of Earth surface | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Percent of Earth surface |
| List of Countries where the numbers to not add up. | 4 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#List of Countries where the numbers to not add up. |
| ranking by area in infoboxes on country article pages. | 4 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#ranking by area in infoboxes on country article pages. |
| The "total" figures for the United States do not add up | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#The "total" figures for the United States do not add up |
| Åland Islands | 5 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Åland Islands |
| Water area figures | 6 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Water area figures |
| Dispute territories between China and India | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Dispute territories between China and India |
| China | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#China |
| United States | 4 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#United States |
| Missing Dependencies and other overseas territories | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Missing Dependencies and other overseas territories |
| France's overseas departments/territories | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#France's overseas departments/territories |
| Kosovo | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Kosovo |
| Different Areas? | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Different Areas? |
| United States Pacific Island Wildlife Refuges | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#United States Pacific Island Wildlife Refuges |
| Canada | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Canada |
| Spain | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Spain |
| Denmark | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Denmark |
| Rank-order column (1,2,3) could be static and separate | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Rank-order column (1,2,3) could be static and separate |
| POV tagged | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#POV tagged |
| Area of China | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Area of China |
| Ethiopia | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Ethiopia |
| Indonesia:"Largest country wholly on islands." | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Indonesia:"Largest country wholly on islands." |
| China is wrong | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#China is wrong |
| Those triangles | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Those triangles |
| Antarctica's lakes | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Antarctica's lakes |
| Ecuador | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Ecuador |
| United States and China | 5 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#United States and China |
| Crown Dependencies/Overseas Territories of the United Kingdom | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Crown Dependencies/Overseas Territories of the United Kingdom |
| UK total figure? | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#UK total figure? |
| Sudan? | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Sudan? |
| List contradicts itself | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#List contradicts itself |
| The Moon | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#The Moon |
| ISO 3166-1 | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#ISO 3166-1 |
| "Australia is not an island" | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#"Australia is not an island" |
| Largest country wholly on islands. | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Largest country wholly on islands. |
| someone deleted canada | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#someone deleted canada |
| 3⁄4 | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#3⁄4 |
| History of 3rd largest country dispute - in short | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#History of 3rd largest country dispute - in short |
| I corrected China and US information | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#I corrected China and US information |
| Third largest country is DISPUTED | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Third largest country is DISPUTED |
| Water in Antarctica | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Water in Antarctica |
| About the list of Area of Bangladesh | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#About the list of Area of Bangladesh |
| Proposed merge with List of countries by total area (graphical) | 4 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Proposed merge with List of countries by total area (graphical) |
| Re: Greenland Island/Continent | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Re: Greenland Island/Continent |
| Incorrect United Sates / China Information | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Incorrect United Sates / China Information |
| Total Area for Bosnia and Herzegovina incorrect | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Total Area for Bosnia and Herzegovina incorrect |
| What is World and Antartica doing in a list of countries? | 5 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#What is World and Antartica doing in a list of countries? |
| Zimbabwean Waters? | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Zimbabwean Waters? |
| Taiwan should not be listed as a country | 8 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Taiwan should not be listed as a country |
| Better accessibility | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Better accessibility |
| Area given for China was computed how? | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Area given for China was computed how? |
| current usa and china numbers | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#current usa and china numbers |
| Saudi Arabia area wrong? | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Saudi Arabia area wrong? |
| Integrated parts of a country listed separately? | 9 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Integrated parts of a country listed separately? |
| Crimea and Sevastopol | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Crimea and Sevastopol |
| Autonomous countries | 7 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Autonomous countries |
| Kingdom of the Netherlands and France? | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Kingdom of the Netherlands and France? |
| page needs temporary protection | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#page needs temporary protection |
| Adding 2 square kilometers removes a square mile? | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Adding 2 square kilometers removes a square mile? |
| Largest Spanish speaking country | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Largest Spanish speaking country |
| Country 164 is not on its own line | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Country 164 is not on its own line |
| Where is France? | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Where is France? |
| the wrong map of russia | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#the wrong map of russia |
| China | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#China 2 |
| US total area | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#US total area |
| Territorial water | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Territorial water |
| Cyprus | 4 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Cyprus |
| Northern Cyprus | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Northern Cyprus |
| Antarctica Is Not a Country | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Antarctica Is Not a Country |
| I re-did China and US entries | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#I re-did China and US entries |
| Israel and Golan Heights | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 1#Israel and Golan Heights |
| Taiwan vs Republic of China | 5 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Taiwan vs Republic of China |
| Incorrect area of Philippines | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Incorrect area of Philippines |
| Russia and Crimea | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Russia and Crimea |
| Athos | 4 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Athos |
| Where do land and water areas come from? | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Where do land and water areas come from? |
| Greenland | 7 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Greenland |
| China–US dispute: Territorial waters are irrelevant if the UNSD source is consistent | 4 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#China–US dispute: Territorial waters are irrelevant if the UNSD source is consistent |
| Sources need updating | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Sources need updating |
| Egypt-Sudan | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Egypt-Sudan |
| Statistical Inconsistencies | 8 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Statistical Inconsistencies |
| Denmark - Largest country in the world? | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Denmark - Largest country in the world? |
| Ivory Coast | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Ivory Coast |
| Water area of the United States | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Water area of the United States |
| Armenia | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Armenia |
| Bir Tawil | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Bir Tawil |
| "Notes" column | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#"Notes" column |
| Dependent Territories | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Dependent Territories |
| Svalbard and Jan Mayen are part of Norway, not dependent territories | 4 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Svalbard and Jan Mayen are part of Norway, not dependent territories |
| Kingdom of Denmark should be added | 32 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Kingdom of Denmark should be added |
| What about Sealand? | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#What about Sealand? |
| External links modified | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#External links modified |
| canada is smaller than china and usa | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#canada is smaller than china and usa |
| What is bigger: USA or China | 21 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#What is bigger: USA or China |
| UK sea territory underestimated | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#UK sea territory underestimated |
| Israel | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Israel |
| Countries greater than 1.5 million | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Countries greater than 1.5 million |
| India | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#India |
| The Philippines: why is the conversion incorrect? | 8 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#The Philippines: why is the conversion incorrect? |
| Australian Antarctic Territory | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Australian Antarctic Territory |
| Including Exclusive Economic Zones | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Including Exclusive Economic Zones |
| External links modified | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#External links modified 2 |
| Rank number | 6 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Rank number |
| Use a different colour code for Russia on the map | 7 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Use a different colour code for Russia on the map |
| Serbia | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Serbia |
| Change "land area" to "dry land area"? | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Change "land area" to "dry land area"? |
| Greenland in Denmark | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Greenland in Denmark |
| Someone’s been tinkering.., | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Someone’s been tinkering.., |
| How should this list deal with Denmark?? | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#How should this list deal with Denmark?? |
| China vs United States size | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#China vs United States size |
| Neutrality / disputed problems of article | 8 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Neutrality / disputed problems of article |
| Mexico is not an Amerindian country | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Mexico is not an Amerindian country |
| Proposal to use Gall–Peters projection | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Proposal to use Gall–Peters projection |
| Please fix some colors | 4 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Please fix some colors |
| Morocco and Western Sahara | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Morocco and Western Sahara |
| Denmark is a country | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Denmark is a country |
| Correct total areas, especially for Island states | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Correct total areas, especially for Island states |
| Dependencies should be included with state | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 2#Dependencies should be included with state |
| Pakistan | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Pakistan |
| The dispute over third and forth place by area is poorly adjudicated. | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#The dispute over third and forth place by area is poorly adjudicated. |
| Semi-protected edit request on 17 July 2019 | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Semi-protected edit request on 17 July 2019 |
| Semi-protected edit request on 12 August 2019 | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Semi-protected edit request on 12 August 2019 |
| France/Ukraine | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#France/Ukraine |
| State of Palestine | 27 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#State of Palestine |
| RFC Should Palestine be numbered? | 45 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#RFC Should Palestine be numbered? |
| European Union | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#European Union |
| Western Sahara | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Western Sahara |
| Why doesn't area of Russia include Crimea? | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Why doesn't area of Russia include Crimea? |
| Semi-protected edit request on 22 May 2020 | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Semi-protected edit request on 22 May 2020 |
| New map and area of Nepal | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#New map and area of Nepal |
| The Danish realm | 7 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#The Danish realm |
| Antarctica | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Antarctica |
| FAQ | 6 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#FAQ |
| Semi-protected edit request on 23 June 2020 | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Semi-protected edit request on 23 June 2020 |
| Water Percentage Figures | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Water Percentage Figures |
| How to deal with Crimea | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#How to deal with Crimea |
| Venezuela area | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Venezuela area |
| Paracel Islands | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Paracel Islands |
| Semi-protected edit request on 8 November 2020 | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Semi-protected edit request on 8 November 2020 |
| Semi-protected edit request on 20 November 2020 | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Semi-protected edit request on 20 November 2020 |
| Semi-protected edit request on 20 December 2020 | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Semi-protected edit request on 20 December 2020 |
| Semi-protected edit request on 27 December 2020 | 5 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Semi-protected edit request on 27 December 2020 |
| Semi-protected edit request on 29 December 2020 | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Semi-protected edit request on 29 December 2020 |
| Including European Union as an entity | 5 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Including European Union as an entity |
| Relative size and location map | 5 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Relative size and location map |
| Semi-protected edit request on March 03 2021 | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Semi-protected edit request on March 03 2021 |
| Lebanon; second smallest country in continental Asia with Palestine being the smallest?? | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Lebanon; second smallest country in continental Asia with Palestine being the smallest?? |
| Rank of America | 7 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Rank of America |
| Semi-protected edit request on 28 May 2021 | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Semi-protected edit request on 28 May 2021 |
| Antarctica is NOT a country | 62 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 4#Antarctica is NOT a country |
| Surfaces misprint? | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Surfaces misprint? |
| Excuse me | 5 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Excuse me |
| Denmark | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Denmark |
| Ambiguity: land area & water area | 4 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Ambiguity: land area & water area |
| Congo Brazzaville seems to be 2 million sq km too large | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Congo Brazzaville seems to be 2 million sq km too large |
| Semi-protected edit request on 13 August 2021 | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Semi-protected edit request on 13 August 2021 |
| Kazakhstan, not a transcontinental country. | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 3#Kazakhstan, not a transcontinental country. |
| seem to be forgetting Australia as one of the largest country.. | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 4#seem to be forgetting Australia as one of the largest country.. |
| Area of the Philippines | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 4#Area of the Philippines |
| 3D Land Surface Area | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 4#3D Land Surface Area |
| Coral Sea Islands | 4 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 4#Coral Sea Islands |
| Wrong data | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 4#Wrong data |
| Percentage format | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 4#Percentage format |
| Crimea | 5 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 4#Crimea |
| Why is Greenland not on the map or the list? | 5 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 4#Why is Greenland not on the map or the list? |
| The United States is not completely in the Western Hemisphere | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 4#The United States is not completely in the Western Hemisphere |
| Antarctica and Greenland | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 4#Antarctica and Greenland |
| Numbering | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 4#Numbering |
| United States coastal/territorial waters | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 4#United States coastal/territorial waters |
| The inclusion of Antarctica | 4 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 4#The inclusion of Antarctica |
| 2/4 | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 4#2/4 |
| UK | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 4#UK |
| U.S. and China | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area#U.S. and China |
| Move discussion in progress | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 4#Move discussion in progress |
| Juan Fernandez | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 4#Juan Fernandez |
| Semi-protected edit request on 1 January 2023 | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area/Archive 4#Semi-protected edit request on 1 January 2023 |
| United States and China (Note 4) | 5 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area#United States and China (Note 4) |
| UK | 5 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area#UK |
| Top 5 | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area#Top 5 |
| Numbering is wrong starting at 12 | 1 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area#Numbering is wrong starting at 12 |
| Semi-protected edit request on 24 February 2023 | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area#Semi-protected edit request on 24 February 2023 |
| Formatting with shorter line length | 3 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area#Formatting with shorter line length |
| French Territories | 6 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area#French Territories |
| Western Sahara Flag | 2 | Talk:List of countries and dependencies by area#Western Sahara Flag |