| Discussion Topic | Replies (estimated) | Archive Link |
|---|
| Landmarks | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 2#Landmarks |
| Revision of 2. Expansion of Space | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 2#Revision of 2. Expansion of Space |
| Redshift: Distance or Recession | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 2#Redshift: Distance or Recession |
| Infrared shift? | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 2#Infrared shift? |
| Wolf Effect | 20 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 3#Wolf Effect |
| Statistical Decay | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 3#Statistical Decay |
| Stretching | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 2#Stretching |
| Expansion Today | 13 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 3#Expansion Today |
| Values of Z | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 3#Values of Z |
| Definition of terms | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 3#Definition of terms |
| Variable particle mass theory | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 3#Variable particle mass theory |
| Request for arbitration | 10 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 3#Request for arbitration |
| Neutrino redshift | 7 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 3#Neutrino redshift |
| Wolf Effect (again) | 74 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 3#Wolf Effect (again) |
| Definition of Redshift | 12 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 3#Definition of Redshift |
| Introduction dummed down | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 3#Introduction dummed down |
| Redshift | 3 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 3#Redshift |
| Redshift and the POV of nonscientist layman Iantresman | 11 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 4#Redshift and the POV of nonscientist layman Iantresman |
| Ian's demonstartion of understanding | 3 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 4#Ian's demonstartion of understanding |
| Can't we just be friends? | 7 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 4#Can't we just be friends? |
| POV pushing section removed | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 5#POV pushing section removed |
| RfC: Request for Comments | 63 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 5#RfC: Request for Comments |
| Redshift and Arp | 8 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 5#Redshift and Arp |
| Red shift or redshift? | 3 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 5#Red shift or redshift? |
| Redshift proposal clarification | 7 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 5#Redshift proposal clarification |
| Perspectives | 7 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 5#Perspectives |
| Criticism | 39 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 5#Criticism |
| Wikipedia:WikiProject Physics | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 5#Wikipedia:WikiProject Physics |
| NPOV removal | 9 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 5#NPOV removal |
| Section removal | 4 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 5#Section removal |
| Protected | 7 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 5#Protected |
| Proposal part (b) | 37 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 5#Proposal part (b) |
| Redshift, the edit war? | 20 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 5#Redshift, the edit war? |
| Compton redshifts | 8 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 5#Compton redshifts |
| 750 Peer-reviewed "Untrivial Redshifts" | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 5#750 Peer-reviewed "Untrivial Redshifts" |
| The Wolf Effect and Hubble's Law | 23 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 5#The Wolf Effect and Hubble's Law |
| Untrivial redshifts - A bibliographical catalogue | 6 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 5#Untrivial redshifts - A bibliographical catalogue |
| Removal of nonstandard cosmology section | 34 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 5#Removal of nonstandard cosmology section |
| Astronomical & laboratory observed redshift phenomenon | 4 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 6#Astronomical & laboratory observed redshift phenomenon |
| More hypocrisy from Joshua Shroeder | 7 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 6#More hypocrisy from Joshua Shroeder |
| Close RfC? | 3 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 6#Close RfC? |
| Raman redshifts | 3 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 6#Raman redshifts |
| Request for Arbitration | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 6#Request for Arbitration |
| NPOV | 28 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 6#NPOV |
| RfC closed or not? | 12 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 6#RfC closed or not? |
| analogous but not equivalent | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 6#analogous but not equivalent |
| Criteria for a redshifting, Doppler like effect | 17 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 6#Criteria for a redshifting, Doppler like effect |
| Improving a criterium of selection of the proposals for Doppler-like redshifts | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 6#Improving a criterium of selection of the proposals for Doppler-like redshifts |
| Please reestablish the focus of this talk page | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#Please reestablish the focus of this talk page |
| peer reviewed papers contra non peer reviewed? | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#peer reviewed papers contra non peer reviewed? |
| Time to bow out | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#Time to bow out |
| Improving a criterium of selection of the proposals for Doppler-like redshifts | 3 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#Improving a criterium of selection of the proposals for Doppler-like redshifts |
| Why I removed the link to tired light | 12 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#Why I removed the link to tired light |
| Olbers' Paradox and 'Gravitational' redshift | 3 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#Olbers' Paradox and 'Gravitational' redshift |
| Marmet garbage | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#Marmet garbage |
| please include the wolf effect | 43 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#please include the wolf effect |
| I have made the change I suggested | 33 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#I have made the change I suggested |
| Clarification from Emil Wolf | 18 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#Clarification from Emil Wolf |
| Direct verifiable quotations supporting the Wolf effect | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#Direct verifiable quotations supporting the Wolf effect |
| Attempting to maintain focus on the scattering issue | 11 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#Attempting to maintain focus on the scattering issue |
| Move to the Wolf effect page | 8 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#Move to the Wolf effect page |
| Options for resolution | 24 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#Options for resolution |
| Explanation of the conflict up until now | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#Explanation of the conflict up until now |
| Resolved? | 16 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#Resolved? |
| "Vacuum redshifts" | 32 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#"Vacuum redshifts" |
| "Classical redshift" | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#"Classical redshift" |
| CREIL | 17 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#CREIL |
| Attempting (again) to focus the discussion and bring sanity to the talk page | 11 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#Attempting (again) to focus the discussion and bring sanity to the talk page |
| I feel like I am being baited by IanTresman. What do Ian and the other editors think? | 27 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#I feel like I am being baited by IanTresman. What do Ian and the other editors think? |
| Undue weight | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#Undue weight |
| Cabal Mediation | 4 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 7#Cabal Mediation |
| Prediction vs. description | 3 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Prediction vs. description |
| See also | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#See also |
| Catastrophists, creationists, and even geocentrists | 3 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Catastrophists, creationists, and even geocentrists |
| Quantum Gravity | 4 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Quantum Gravity |
| Redshift Quantization | 24 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Redshift Quantization |
| Fine structure constant confusion? | 4 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Fine structure constant confusion? |
| Clarification about the context of redshift quantization | 12 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Clarification about the context of redshift quantization |
| Dumbed down introduction | 3 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Dumbed down introduction |
| The relative change in wavelength z | 3 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#The relative change in wavelength z |
| Ian's edits | 7 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Ian's edits |
| Ready for FA? | 3 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Ready for FA? |
| Cosmological statement | 6 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Cosmological statement |
| Redshift criticism (refactoring confusion) | 3 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Redshift criticism (refactoring confusion) |
| Back to Redshift Quantization | 10 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Back to Redshift Quantization |
| Redshift criticism (Ian's proposal) | 6 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Redshift criticism (Ian's proposal) |
| Overview change | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Overview change |
| Going way back in time | 3 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Going way back in time |
| Frame transformations | 11 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Frame transformations |
| Michel's letter | 6 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Michel's letter |
| Intrinsic redshift | 4 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Intrinsic redshift |
| Observation vs theory | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Observation vs theory |
| Alternative redshift theories | 7 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Alternative redshift theories |
| Redshift mechanisms | 7 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Redshift mechanisms |
| Undue weight | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 8#Undue weight |
| frequency: ν or f | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#frequency: ν or f |
| Edits to the headings | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#Edits to the headings |
| Cosmological redshift | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#Cosmological redshift |
| Doppler redshift of source | 10 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#Doppler redshift of source |
| Redshift transformations | 20 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#Redshift transformations |
| Verifiable quotes on "redshift mechanisms" | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#Verifiable quotes on "redshift mechanisms" |
| note for InvictaHOG | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#note for InvictaHOG |
| I still don't get it. | 11 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#I still don't get it. |
| Refs | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#Refs |
| The first two paragraphs | 6 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#The first two paragraphs |
| Redshift mechanisms | 30 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#Redshift mechanisms |
| Poor notes | 19 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#Poor notes |
| Congratulations | 3 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#Congratulations |
| History of Redshift | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#History of Redshift |
| Using the Wolf Effect as an example in physical opitcs/radiative transfer | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#Using the Wolf Effect as an example in physical opitcs/radiative transfer |
| Congratulations | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#Congratulations 2 |
| Congratulations | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#Congratulations 3 |
| Photograph | 8 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#Photograph |
| Plasma Redshift and Tired Light | 18 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#Plasma Redshift and Tired Light |
| Mechanism text | 4 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#Mechanism text |
| majorish edit | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#majorish edit |
| List or separate article for unconventional theories? | 17 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#List or separate article for unconventional theories? |
| Red shift in one direction = blue shift in opposite direction and vice versa? | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#Red shift in one direction = blue shift in opposite direction and vice versa? |
| Relative Doppler Effect question | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#Relative Doppler Effect question |
| Junk Science? | 3 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 9#Junk Science? |
| Title and spinoff problems | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#Title and spinoff problems |
| Energy considerations | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#Energy considerations |
| blue shift | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#blue shift |
| Additional Mechanism | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#Additional Mechanism |
| clarification of shifts | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#clarification of shifts |
| Different kinds of redshift | 30 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#Different kinds of redshift |
| Halton Arp | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#Halton Arp |
| See also | 6 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#See also |
| Including some implausible hypotheses in the main article | 8 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#Including some implausible hypotheses in the main article |
| The current sentence looks good to me | 12 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#The current sentence looks good to me |
| Summary of Viewpoints about the prominence of Halton Arp, Intrinsic redshift, and Tired light and how to proceed from here | 8 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#Summary of Viewpoints about the prominence of Halton Arp, Intrinsic redshift, and Tired light and how to proceed from here |
| Tired light | 5 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#Tired light |
| Redshift vs Blue shift | 4 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#Redshift vs Blue shift |
| Rewrite in lead | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#Rewrite in lead |
| Confused image and caption | 8 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#Confused image and caption |
| Seconding the suggestion of severe subtlety | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#Seconding the suggestion of severe subtlety |
| Quasars | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#Quasars |
| line element | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#line element |
| Doppler effect works great in Aether | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#Doppler effect works great in Aether |
| Hubble finds a new contender for galaxy distance record | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#Hubble finds a new contender for galaxy distance record |
| "Two different sources of redshift" figure label | 13 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#"Two different sources of redshift" figure label |
| Alternative explanations besides cosmological expansion? | 8 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#Alternative explanations besides cosmological expansion? |
| frequency versus wavelength | 3 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#frequency versus wavelength |
| Other causes of redshift effect | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#Other causes of redshift effect |
| Derivation of cosmological redshift | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 10#Derivation of cosmological redshift |
| Anomalous Objects | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Anomalous Objects |
| Redshift used for Radar Guns? | 8 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Redshift used for Radar Guns? |
| Hubble on Expanding Universe | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Hubble on Expanding Universe |
| Edit 6 March | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Edit 6 March |
| Nonlinear scaling factor | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Nonlinear scaling factor |
| suspected error in redshift for theta= 0 formula | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#suspected error in redshift for theta= 0 formula |
| Error/lack of clarity in geodesic equation | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Error/lack of clarity in geodesic equation |
| Redshift as an unsuitable measure of distance | 11 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Redshift as an unsuitable measure of distance |
| Cosmic Redshift Mathematical Derivation | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Cosmic Redshift Mathematical Derivation |
| External links modified | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#External links modified |
| External links modified | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#External links modified 2 |
| Simplification & clarification in 'Redshift formulae' section | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Simplification & clarification in 'Redshift formulae' section |
| Suggestion to help the simpletons (We wave hello) | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Suggestion to help the simpletons (We wave hello) |
| Should say more about Arp's theory perhaps in historical section | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Should say more about Arp's theory perhaps in historical section |
| Inertial Redshift article redirected to Expanding Universe section | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Inertial Redshift article redirected to Expanding Universe section |
| Merge blueshift into redshift | 5 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Merge blueshift into redshift |
| Updating Highest redshift section | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Updating Highest redshift section |
| English | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#English |
| Earliest use in print | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Earliest use in print |
| Wikipedia:Unreviewed featured articles/2020/2004–2009 | 3 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Wikipedia:Unreviewed featured articles/2020/2004–2009 |
| Classical redshift | 17 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Classical redshift |
| redshift diagram seems wrong | 3 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#redshift diagram seems wrong |
| Redshift of gravitational waves | 1 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Redshift of gravitational waves |
| Charts and age/lookback calculation | 9 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Charts and age/lookback calculation |
| simultaneous | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#simultaneous |
| Request for rearrangement | 3 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Request for rearrangement |
| Age of the universe by redshift | 2 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Age of the universe by redshift |
| History section is WP:Original research fine | 6 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#History section is WP:Original research fine |
| Redshift as the "de Sitter Effect" | 4 | Talk:Redshift/Archive 11#Redshift as the "de Sitter Effect" |
| ENGVAR | 3 | Talk:Redshift#ENGVAR |
| Blue | 1 | Talk:Redshift#Blue |
| Split blueshift? | 7 | Talk:Redshift#Split blueshift? |