| Discussion Topic | Replies (estimated) | Archive Link |
|---|
| Issues with "A Second Paradox" | 5 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 1#Issues with "A Second Paradox" |
| Logic | 12 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 1#Logic |
| An Alternative Scenario | 11 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 1#An Alternative Scenario |
| Another Explanation of the Error | 9 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 1#Another Explanation of the Error |
| buhh | 56 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 1#buhh |
| Not really a paradox? | 3 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 1#Not really a paradox? |
| Solution to third paradox | 6 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 1#Solution to third paradox |
| Vote for Deletion | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 1#Vote for Deletion |
| Paradox of probability? | 434 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 1#Paradox of probability? |
| 3rd paradox | 5 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 1#3rd paradox |
| A strategy that gives you more than a 50% chance of picking the best envelope | 45 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 1#A strategy that gives you more than a 50% chance of picking the best envelope |
| The Envelope Paradox in Economics | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 1#The Envelope Paradox in Economics |
| History of the paradox | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 1#History of the paradox |
| The Most Basic Version is Lacking (!) | 4 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 1#The Most Basic Version is Lacking (!) |
| The introduction | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#The introduction |
| Solution to 2nd paradox | 64 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 1#Solution to 2nd paradox |
| What is the paradox? | 20 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 1#What is the paradox? |
| Terminological suggestion: "solution" -> "discussion" | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 1#Terminological suggestion: "solution" -> "discussion" |
| Marcus Moore | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 1#Marcus Moore |
| Merge | 3 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#Merge |
| Tad's original research | 3 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#Tad's original research |
| New question | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 1#New question |
| The 'an even harder problem' does not make sense | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#The 'an even harder problem' does not make sense |
| A Harder Problem | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#A Harder Problem |
| Ranking of Problems | 7 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#Ranking of Problems |
| Recent Edits - lets' express the probelm clearly before going into Bayesiana -Do we need to START with Bayes? | 10 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#Recent Edits - lets' express the probelm clearly before going into Bayesiana -Do we need to START with Bayes? |
| "solution" -> "discussion" | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#"solution" -> "discussion" |
| One stupid persons viewpoint | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#One stupid persons viewpoint |
| Arguments page | 3 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#Arguments page |
| Proposed solution of the original problem | 23 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#Proposed solution of the original problem |
| Use of 'we' and 'you' | 4 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#Use of 'we' and 'you' |
| Merge with Necktie Paradox | 11 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 3#Merge with Necktie Paradox |
| Formatting of References | 6 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#Formatting of References |
| Equation source | 4 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#Equation source |
| solution | 5 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#solution |
| crazy | 6 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#crazy |
| This is a solved problem, not an open problem | 7 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#This is a solved problem, not an open problem |
| There is no benefit to switching | 7 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#There is no benefit to switching |
| Archived Harder Problem | 5 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 3#Archived Harder Problem |
| Why no game-terminating event? | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#Why no game-terminating event? |
| the danger of concrete examples | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#the danger of concrete examples |
| Comments about the Wikipedia Article | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#Comments about the Wikipedia Article |
| Constructive suggestions | 6 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#Constructive suggestions |
| Suggestion to remove non-probabilistic version | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#Suggestion to remove non-probabilistic version |
| So-called open problem | 27 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 3#So-called open problem |
| I propose adding a link in external references | 3 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 2#I propose adding a link in external references |
| Generalizing the fallacity | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 3#Generalizing the fallacity |
| Calling all Probability Theorists: This article needs an edit | 4 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 3#Calling all Probability Theorists: This article needs an edit |
| Much better now | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 3#Much better now |
| Disruptide edits by iNic again | 11 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 3#Disruptide edits by iNic again |
| My issues with the current statement of the problem and solution | 12 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 3#My issues with the current statement of the problem and solution |
| Two Envelopes "Paradox" is Resolved - New sources | 14 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 3#Two Envelopes "Paradox" is Resolved - New sources |
| lack of explanation | 3 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 3#lack of explanation |
| Some organisation | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 3#Some organisation |
| Stop substantially editing this if you aren't an expert | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 3#Stop substantially editing this if you aren't an expert |
| Rewrite (2011-04-08) | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 3#Rewrite (2011-04-08) |
| Some thoughts | 17 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 3#Some thoughts |
| Proposal to delete two unsourced and unhelpful sections | 19 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 3#Proposal to delete two unsourced and unhelpful sections |
| Lead thoughts | 10 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 4#Lead thoughts |
| Intro | 6 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 3#Intro |
| Three level paradox | 7 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 4#Three level paradox |
| Proposed structure for the article | 6 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 4#Proposed structure for the article |
| Exchange paradox | 3 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 4#Exchange paradox |
| Sources | 6 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 4#Sources |
| Non probabilistic version | 4 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 4#Non probabilistic version |
| More sources | 6 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 4#More sources |
| Multiple issues tag | 3 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 4#Multiple issues tag |
| Completed reorganization of material | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 4#Completed reorganization of material |
| Simplest resolution missed. | 24 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 4#Simplest resolution missed. |
| 'Impossible distribution' resolution superfluous? | 8 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 4#'Impossible distribution' resolution superfluous? |
| The lead | 16 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 4#The lead |
| Is TEP philosophy or mathematics? | 18 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 5#Is TEP philosophy or mathematics? |
| TEP, Anna Karenina, and Aliens | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 4#TEP, Anna Karenina, and Aliens |
| Dubious importance | 18 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 4#Dubious importance |
| Puzzled | 22 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 4#Puzzled |
| This is not a paradox | 4 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 4#This is not a paradox |
| Can we all agree on the following? | 18 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 5#Can we all agree on the following? |
| How is the article now? | 12 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 5#How is the article now? |
| Singular or plural envelopes | 3 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 5#Singular or plural envelopes |
| Is TEP a problem in Philosophy or Probability or Logic (continued) | 6 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 5#Is TEP a problem in Philosophy or Probability or Logic (continued) |
| One reasons these puzzles cause so much argument. | 15 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 5#One reasons these puzzles cause so much argument. |
| Redirect also from Necktie paradox? | 6 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 5#Redirect also from Necktie paradox? |
| Essay on Probability Notation | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 5#Essay on Probability Notation |
| Quantum Two Envelopes Problem | 7 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 5#Quantum Two Envelopes Problem |
| Littlewood's problem and Schroedinger's problem | 3 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 5#Littlewood's problem and Schroedinger's problem |
| TEP Sources | 3 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 5#TEP Sources |
| Elementary solution | 86 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 5#Elementary solution |
| Law of Diminishing returns | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 5#Law of Diminishing returns |
| Falk (2008), Falk and Nickerson (2009), Nickerson and Falk (2005) | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 6#Falk (2008), Falk and Nickerson (2009), Nickerson and Falk (2005) |
| The error in the switching argument | 14 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 6#The error in the switching argument |
| Falk and Konold (1992) | 7 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 6#Falk and Konold (1992) |
| Chase | 3 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 6#Chase |
| 3 Contexts, 2 Aims gives 6 problems, 6 solutions | 5 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 6#3 Contexts, 2 Aims gives 6 problems, 6 solutions |
| Moved "sources" to talk page | 11 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 6#Moved "sources" to talk page |
| Second variant does not require Envelope A to be opened | 11 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 6#Second variant does not require Envelope A to be opened |
| Question from an anon. | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 6#Question from an anon. |
| Article gives wrong impression about status of TEP | 5 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 6#Article gives wrong impression about status of TEP |
| First resolution | 46 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 6#First resolution |
| Renamed sections | 6 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 6#Renamed sections |
| Remove Section "Extensions"? | 3 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 6#Remove Section "Extensions"? |
| A solution which ANYONE can understand | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 6#A solution which ANYONE can understand |
| Introduction to Solutions | 10 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 6#Introduction to Solutions |
| A common resolution | 37 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 7#A common resolution |
| Attribution of common (philosopher's) solution | 3 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 7#Attribution of common (philosopher's) solution |
| Introduction to resolutions based on probability theory | 19 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 7#Introduction to resolutions based on probability theory |
| A common resolution | 12 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 7#A common resolution 2 |
| Great work | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 7#Great work |
| Resolution based upon time constraints | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 7#Resolution based upon time constraints |
| Formatting error | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 7#Formatting error |
| In a mess again | 44 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 7#In a mess again |
| Recent edit warring | 6 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 7#Recent edit warring |
| Edit warring | 30 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 8#Edit warring |
| Undue Weight to Random Primary Source | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 8#Undue Weight to Random Primary Source |
| Four different views | 10 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 8#Four different views |
| Page protection | 8 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 8#Page protection |
| Request for comments | 52 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 9#Request for comments |
| Protected edit request on 28 October 2014 | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 8#Protected edit request on 28 October 2014 |
| Secondary sources | 3 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 8#Secondary sources |
| How to structure article | 8 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 8#How to structure article |
| Quotes | 4 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 8#Quotes |
| Tsikogiannopoulos | 6 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 8#Tsikogiannopoulos |
| Wrong Introduction | 7 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 8#Wrong Introduction |
| New section headings | 11 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 8#New section headings |
| Some proposed words for the simple description of the E(B|A=a) resolution | 7 | [[Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 8#Some proposed words for the simple description of the E(B|A=a) resolution]] |
| A simple example | 21 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 8#A simple example |
| Making things too complicated too quickly | 17 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 8#Making things too complicated too quickly |
| Tsikogiannopoulos returns | 30 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 9#Tsikogiannopoulos returns |
| Revised and expanded first resolution | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 9#Revised and expanded first resolution |
| Coin toss variation | 3 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 9#Coin toss variation |
| Added simple version of mathematical interpretation | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 9#Added simple version of mathematical interpretation |
| Time to remove dead wood | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 9#Time to remove dead wood |
| McGilvery | 3 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 9#McGilvery |
| Proposed introductory wording for the logical/philosophical resolution section | 19 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 9#Proposed introductory wording for the logical/philosophical resolution section |
| Ali Baba variant | 4 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 9#Ali Baba variant |
| Proposal for mathematical resolution | 15 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 9#Proposal for mathematical resolution |
| Is the "new paradox" really defused? | 14 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 9#Is the "new paradox" really defused? |
| Lee (2013) | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 9#Lee (2013) |
| What does the letter 'A' stand for? | 4 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 10#What does the letter 'A' stand for? |
| Missing a simple resolution | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 9#Missing a simple resolution |
| The forgotten fact | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem#The forgotten fact |
| New publication coming up | 4 | Talk:Two envelopes problem#New publication coming up |
| Don't put article content in Talk page | 6 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 10#Don't put article content in Talk page |
| Another reference | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem#Another reference |
| Bibliography | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem#Bibliography |
| List of inconsistencies | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem#List of inconsistencies |
| How is this correct? | 4 | Talk:Two envelopes problem/Archive 10#How is this correct? |
| Would be useful to put the simple, non-technical explanation first | 2 | Talk:Two envelopes problem#Would be useful to put the simple, non-technical explanation first |
| Monty Hall | 1 | Talk:Two envelopes problem#Monty Hall |
| Detailed derivations moved from the article | 6 | Talk:Two envelopes problem#Detailed derivations moved from the article |