User:Alvestrand/Unity Church notes
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Unity Church has some troublesome edit stuff. "Edit warring" is a reasonable term.
Dramatis personae
Most of these are IP addresses, strangely. Some of them seem to be the same.
- 24.28.6.209 (talk · contribs · IP contribs · WHOIS) - Austin RoadRunner subscriber. prefers to call Unity "bible-based" and "Christianity-related". Militantly so.
- 24.215.255.192 (talk · contribs · IP contribs · WHOIS) - NYC Earthlink subscriber. prefers to call Unity "Metaphysical" and "God-related". Blocked for vandalism 2007-10-24. Only active 2007-10-24.
- 24.215.255.87 (talk · contribs · IP contribs · WHOIS) - NYC EarthLink subscriber. Placing "unreferenced" and "notability" tags 2008-02-24. Removing "Christian denomination" category 2008-03-03.
- 66.108.4.122 (talk · contribs · IP contribs · WHOIS) - NYC RoadRunner subscriber - restores tags placed by 24.215.255.87 2008-02-25
- 66.108.106.238 (talk · contribs · IP contribs · WHOIS) - NYC RoadRunner subscriber - repeats rolled-back entries by 24.215.255.87 2008-03-03
- 66.108.111.91 (talk · contribs · IP contribs · WHOIS) - NYC RoadRunner subscriber. same viewpoints as 24.215.255.192 . Also blocked for vandalism 2007-10-24.
- 68.77.10.17 (talk · contribs · IP contribs · WHOIS) - linked via Ameritech, tag "Rback5". Edits on 2008-03-02, deleting material.
- 68.77.25.28 (talk · contribs · IP contribs · WHOIS) - AT&T netblock, emhril.sbcglobal.net - likely Chicago. Edits on 2009-02-20, deleting material.
- 68.200.0.249 (talk · contribs · IP contribs · WHOIS) - Tampa, Florida RoadRunnier subscriber. Edits on 2009-02-13, deleting material.
- 69.22.232.156 (talk · contribs · IP contribs · WHOIS) - NYC Mindspring subscriber. Active from 2007-10-23 to 2007-10-24.
- 71.42.142.238 (talk · contribs · IP contribs · WHOIS) - Austin RoadRunner subscriber. prefers to call Unity "bible-based" and "Christianity-related" . Denies being Scottandrewhutchins .
- 72.145.116.201 (talk · contribs · IP contribs · WHOIS) - Atlanta BellSouth subscriber. "Semi" bible based? .
- 72.225.239.38 (talk · contribs · IP contribs · WHOIS) - NYC Verizon suscriber. Removes "Bible-based" and "Christian denomination".
- 74.73.176.161 (talk · contribs · IP contribs · WHOIS) - NYC RoadRunner subscriber. Adds "Feminism" category to article on 2008-09-24 and on 2008-10-25.
- 151.202.52.86 (talk · contribs · IP contribs · WHOIS) - NYC Verizon subscriber. Emphasizes the "new thought" link .
- 151.202.182.100 (talk · contribs · IP contribs · WHOIS) - NYC Verizon subscriber. prefers to call Unity "Metaphysical" and "God-related" , possibly JGG59, see .
- 159.83.252.233 (talk · contribs · IP contribs · WHOIS) - Los Angeles based - adds unreferenced history section on 2008-09-24
- Aleta (talk · contribs) - just another editor.
- C.Fred (talk · contribs) - just a drive-by formatter.
- Catherineyronwode (talk · contribs) - long time contributor, thinks highly of User:JGG59 .
- Hrafn (talk · contribs) - strongly enforces requirement for sourcing statements.
- JGG59 (talk · contribs) - feels victimized by the IP-based POV-pushers . Seems to deny being some of the IP-address participants .
- Kenosis (talk · contribs) - active since 2006, active on article in May 2009.
- Kwhistle (talk · contribs) - appeared on May 18, 2009; has edited no other article. SPA. See for geolocation (likely southern California).
- Ricky81682 (talk · contribs) - just another editor
- Scottandrewhutchins (talk · contribs) - seems to be just another editor, and a knowledgeable one.
Points under dispute
Whether Unity is a "metaphysical" church or a "Bible-based" one. Lots of supporting details.