User:Shot info/ACE2008
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Just my thoughts on how I think I will vote based on nominee’s responses to the questions and my own personal thoughts and interactions (or lack thereof). Note that “not an admin” to me is just a cop out and an enforcement of Wikipedia’s growing class divide between the “Haves” and “Havenots”.
 | 2008 Arbitration Committee Elections • General Guide • Voting is now closed, and the final results were announced on December 20. Wikipedia Signpost Candidate Profiles • Individuals' guides: AGK • Caspian blue (meta) • CT Cooper • east718 • Elonka • Franamax • Giggy • GlassCobra • Lar • Majorly • MBisanz • MZMcBride • PhilKnight • Rschen7754 • Rspeer • SandyGeorgia • Shot info |
Those that are blank are those that I’m thinking about. Chances are they will be automatic opposes if they have limited article space work such that I cannot gauge who or what they are.
| User | Comments | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| AnthonyQBachler | Nope – needs more articlespace edits....a lot more in fact. |  Oppose |
| BillMasen | ||
| Carcharoth | Performance during Matthew Hoffman case was suspect. | Oppose |
| Casliber | Yes, good nominee cuts thru some of the guff (not all) supports science (generally speaking). And for that - receives my support. |  Support |
| Charles Matthews | Nope – tends to support anti-science civil POV pushers. Besides time for new blood - current ArbCom seems to making too many determinations which the Community disagrees with. | Oppose |
| Cool Hand Luke | Excellent editor, cool head. | Support |
| Coren | ||
| Dream Focus | ||
| Fish and karate | ||
| George The Dragon | ||
| Gwen Gale | Maybe next time. | Oppose |
| Hemlock Martinis | ||
| Jayvdb | ||
| Jdforrester | IRC – need we say more? Besides time for some new blood. | Oppose |
| Jehochman | Yes, most definitely. Gets to the heart of the matter much to the undisguised disgust of those who would rather they get brushed under the carpet. Although I have to admit, he seems to be lately (ie/ in the last couple of months) trying to obtain a "middle ground" which is just presenting himself as highly confused rather than the decisive individual we have all being familiar with. This could be a result of him attempting to "retreat to the centre" in order to be more presentable to his detractors for this ArbCom. I honestly hope it as, only as the new-Jehochman is not the Jehochman that I voted support for in this election. I will definitely oppose the new-Jehochman in future ArbCom elections. | Support |
| Justice America | Nah - need another couple of thousand articlespace edits. So at this rate, maybe in 40 or so years time? | Oppose |
| Kmweber | ||
| Lankiveil | ||
| lifebaka | ||
| Privatemusings | ||
| Risker | Good to see wanting to get on board. Pro-science. | Support |
| Rlevse | Oppose | |
| RMHED | Excellent nominee – pro science. | Support |
| Roger Davies | Wow, this guys certainly has slipped under my radar. I like what he has done and his responses to many questions. I also like the fact that I haven't encountered him which tends to imply that he stays well outside the dramazone. A lot of his work indicates that he is pro science, and I like pro-science. | Support |
| Sam Korn | ||
| Shell Kinney | Elonka meatpuppet (see WR). Although she does appear to be moving out of that sphere in recent times. Maybe next year. | Oppose |
| SirFozzie | Like how this guy edits and how he acts in the moar dramaz. Good nominee. | Support |
| The Fat Man Who Never Came Back | While seems flippant – it only seems to be to upseting Those-Who-Should-Know-Better. When serious – has excellent grasp on the issue(s). Heck even when flippant still has a grasp on the issue(s). | Support |
| Trojanpony | ||
| Vassyana | Yes. Pro-science | Support |
| White Cat | ||
| WilyD | ||
| Wizardman | Dang - on the whole I quite like Wizardman and his edits but this response just screams to me that he's more interested in pleasing those who don't understand science and who fail to accomdate it. | Oppose |
| WJBscribe | Suspect - Elonka meat puppet (see comments on WR) | Oppose |