Weldon Mathis

When Teamster president Jackie Presser was diagnosed with cancer and took a four-month leave of absence on May 5, 1988, Mathis was named interim president.

Presser was subsequently diagnosed with brain cancer, setting off a power struggle within the union. The members of the union's freight and warehouse and its air freight divisions voted overwhelmingly against their respective three-year national contracts after Mathis took over. But Mathis declared each contract "ratified" because the "no" vote fell short of the two-thirds needed to reject a contract and authorize a strike. The contract votes weakened Mathis's support on the union's executive board because Mathis was the highest-ranking official involved in the talks.

Mathis's support among the union's leadership was never strong. Mathis was considered much more liberal Presser or the rest of the Teamsters' leadership at the time, and he was much more in favor of participating fully in AFL-CIO.

Mathis was challenged by a faction of conservative Teamsters led by Joseph Trerotola, the union's First Vice President. Trerotola was deeply angered by the 1986 constitutional amendment which allowed Mathis to assume the presidency, and he began building a coalition to oust him. When Mathis called a meeting in Arizona (where Presser was being treated), Trerotola refused to attend. Initially, possible challengers included Joseph W. Morgan (who had sought to become interim president after Roy Lee Williams' resignation in 1983, Walter Shea (director of the Eastern Conference of Teamsters in Washington, D.C.), Donald Peters (a Teamster leader in Chicago), and Arnie Weinmeister (a Teamster official in Washington state and protégé of former interim president George Mock).

Mathis suffered another blow to his candidacy on June 28, 1988, when federal officials filed suit in federal court to impose a trusteeship on the Teamsters union..

Presser died on July 9, 1988, triggering an election for a new president.

But at an executive board meeting on July 18, 1988, Mathis was unseated as president in favor of William J. McCarthy, president of the New England Conference of Teamsters. McCarthy, a protégé of Jimmy Hoffa, emerged as a candidate days before the vote. He was seen as a much more aggressive leader than Mathis. McCarthy—who led the opposition to the freight and warehouse contract—promised to fight the government's trusteeship suit, adopt a more confrontational collective bargaining posture, end the union's thaw toward the rest of the AFL-CIO, and endorse a George H. W. Bush in the 1988 presidential election. Peters, Shea and Weinmeister pulled out of the running, throwing their support behind McCarthy. After a bitter, rancorous, two-and-a-half-hour board meeting, the board voted 9-to-8 to select McCarthy as the union's new president. Vice president Daniel Ligurotis of Chicago cast the deciding vote.

In late December 1988, the federal government sued to overturn Mathis's 1987 election as president of Local 728.

In March 1989, Mathis signed an agreement with the Department of Justice. He consented to aggressively seek internal reforms in the union in exchange for being dropped from the government's labor racketeering suit.

The Teamsters reached an agreement with the Justice Department on March 12, 1989, in which the union agreed to institute internal reforms in order to end corruption and improve the democratic nature of its elections.

Mathis was chosen by the executive board in 1990 to run for re-election as part of an incumbent slate. President McCarthy declined to run for health reasons, and the board selected R.V. Durham, an international vice president, to run as their candidate for president.

In February 1991, Mathis backed a decision by Durham to reject a McCarthy-backed candidate for an empty vice presidential seat. The move was seen as an attempt to put political distance between the Durham candidacy and the McCarthy administration, which was increasingly unpopular with Teamster members. In retaliation, the board sued McCarthy and Mathis for labor racketeering.

A week later, on February 8, 1991, Mathis recommended that the Teamster executive council look into the bidding process McCarthy used to award his son-in-law a contract to print the union magazine. Mathis's move was widely seen as a possible "coup attempt": If McCarthy were found to have committed improper acts, he would be forced to resign—allowing Mathis to become president of the union as well as be seen as a reformer. But the Teamster general board deadlocked 7–7 over the issue, and no investigation was made.

On April 10, 1991, Mathis withdrew from the race for the secretary-treasurer position. Durham replaced him with Walter Shea.

Shea attempted to oust McCarthy in June 1991, once more charging that McCarthy should step down immediately over the contract awarded to his son-in-law. A court-appointed administrator of the Teamsters had ruled that McCarthy had improperly awarded the printing contract but did not seek charges against him. A federal district court judge agreed with that decision. McCarthy turned the meeting of the Teamster executive board over to Mathis, who subsequently ruled that no vote could be taken until after the Teamster convention.

Mathis retired from his post as secretary-treasurer on October 31, 1991, two months early.

Mathis and his wife, the former Myrtle Henson, had five children. Two of Mathis's sons, who controlled Local 728, were voted out of office in a federally monitored election. Rather than return to Georgia, Mathis retired to Florida.

Weldon Mathis died of cancer on October 20, 2001, in Ormond Beach, Florida.

• Ball, Karen. "Teamsters Official Recommends Probe of Printing Contract." Associated Press. February 8, 1991.
• Ball, Karen. "Teamsters President McCarthy Won't Run for Re-Election." Associated Press. October 10, 1990.
• Butterfield, Bruce D. "Teamster's Bid to Oust McCarthy Falls Short." Boston Globe. June 22, 1991.
• Butterfield, Bruce D. "Teamster Chief Denies Naming New Treasurer." Boston Globe. October 31, 1991.
• Crowe, Kenneth C. "Teamster Chief Dodges Probe." Newsday. February 16, 1991.
• Crowe, Kenneth C. "Teamsters' Torch Passing to Mathis." Newsday. July 11, 1988.
• Crowe, Kenneth C. "Upset in Teamsters Ticket." Newsday. April 11, 1991.
• Doyle, John M. "Tentative Pact Reached before Start of Teamsters Rackets Case." Associated Press. March 13, 1989.
• Eblen, Tom. "Teamster Power Struggle Likely." Chicago Tribune. July 12, 1988.
• "Government Files Suit Seeking New Election In Teamster Official's Local." Associated Press. December 29, 1988.
• McKenna, Jon. "Teamster Vote Will Test Mathis Family." Atlanta Business Chronicle. April 23, 1990.
• Noble, Kenneth B. "Teamsters, Rejecting Acting Chief, Pick New Englander as President." New York Times. July 16, 1988.
• Noble, Kenneth B. "With President of Union Ailing, Teamsters Face a Power Struggle." New York Times. May 23, 1988.
• "Presser's Handpicked Heir Upset in Teamster Election." Los Angeles Times. July 15, 1988.
• Schulz, John D. "Teamsters Union Slashes Payroll, 39 of 1990's 50 Top Earners Gone." Traffic World. September 28, 1992.
• Serrin, William "Presser Wins 5-Year Presidency at Jubilant Teamsters' Convention." New York Times. May 22, 1986.
• Shenon, Philip. "U.S. Sues to Oust Teamster Chiefs; Seeks Trustee to Oversee Election." New York Times. June 29, 1988.
• Swoboda, Frank. "McCarthy Leads for Teamsters' Top Job." Washington Post. July 15, 1988.
• Swoboda, Frank. "No. 2 Teamster Settles Charges, Vows Reforms." Washington Post. March 9, 1989.
• Swoboda, Frank. "Teamsters President Challenged." Washington Post. February 1, 1991.
• "Teamster Chief Taking Leave." Associated Press. May 6, 1988.
• "Teamster Chief Won't Seek Re-election in '91." Associated Press. October 11, 1990.
• "Teamsters Mourn Passing of Weldon Mathis." Press release. International Brotherhood of Teamsters. October 24, 2001.
• "Union Leaders Sue Teamster Chief." Chicago Tribune. February 1, 1991.
• Who's Who in Finance and Industry. New Providence, N.J.: Marquis Who's Who, 1989. ISBN 0-8379-0326-2
• Yancey, Matt. "Boston Teamsters Official Eyed For Top Union Job." Associated Press. July 11, 1988.