| 1916 Game Log: 65â89 (Home: 37â40; Away: 28â49) |
April: 6â8 (Home: 3â1; Away: 3â7)
| # | Date | Opponent | Score | Win | Loss | Save | Attendance | Record |
| 1 | April 12 | @ Cardinals | 1â2 | Doak | Kantlehner (0â1) | â | â | 0â1 |
| 2 | April 13 | @ Cardinals | 4â0 | Adams (1â0) | Meadows | â | â | 1â1 |
| 3 | April 14 | @ Cardinals | 3â5 | Jasper | Harmon (0â1) | Griner | â | 1â2 |
| 4 | April 15 | @ Cardinals | 6â1 | Mamaux (1â0) | Hall | â | â | 2â2 |
| 5 | April 16 | @ Reds | 1â6 | Toney | Miller (0â1) | â | â | 2â3 |
| 6 | April 17 | @ Reds | 10â1 | Kantlehner (1â1) | Dale | â | â | 3â3 |
| 7 | April 18 | @ Reds | 3â4 (10) | Schneider | Adams (1â1) | â | â | 3â4 |
| 8 | April 20 | Cardinals | 0â5 | Meadows | Mamaux (1â1) | Sallee | â | 3â5 |
| 9 | April 21 | Cardinals | 8â0 | Harmon (1â1) | Steele | â | â | 4â5 |
| 10 | April 23 | @ Cubs | 0â3 | McConnell | Kantlehner (1â2) | â | 16,000 | 4â6 |
| 11 | April 26 | @ Cubs | 3â6 | Lavender | Adams (1â2) | Prendergast | â | 4â7 |
| 12 | April 28 | Reds | 5â1 | Harmon (2â1) | Schneider | â | â | 5â7 |
| 13 | April 29 | Reds | 2â1 | Mamaux (2â1) | Toney | Miller (1) | â | 6â7 |
| 14 | April 30 | @ Reds | 7â8 | Schneider | Harmon (2â2) | â | â | 6â8 |
|
May: 11â14 (Home: 6â12; Away: 5â2)
| # | Date | Opponent | Score | Win | Loss | Save | Attendance | Record |
| 15 | May 1 | @ Reds | 0â3 | Mitchell | Adams (1â3) | â | â | 6â9 |
| 16 | May 4 | Cubs | 4â2 | Cooper (1â0) | Lavender | â | 4,000 | 7â9 |
| 17 | May 5 | Cubs | 3â5 (13) | Seaton | Kantlehner (1â3) | â | â | 7â10 |
| 18 | May 6 | Cubs | 1â2 | Vaughn | Adams (1â4) | â | 8,000 | 7â11 |
| 19 | May 7 | @ Cubs | 1â0 | Kantlehner (2â3) | Lavender | â | 19,000 | 8â11 |
| 20 | May 8 | @ Cubs | 1â2 | McConnell | Cooper (1â1) | â | â | 8â12 |
| 21 | May 8 | @ Cubs | 6â4 | Mamaux (3â1) | Packard | â | â | 9â12 |
| 22 | May 9 | Giants | 5â13 | Tesreau | Harmon (2â3) | Mathewson | â | 9â13 |
| 23 | May 10 | Giants | 1â7 | Anderson | Adams (1â5) | â | 2,000 | 9â14 |
| 24 | May 11 | Giants | 2â3 | Perritt | Kantlehner (2â4) | Stroud | 2,000 | 9â15 |
| 25 | May 12 | Giants | 2â3 (10) | Schauer | Mamaux (3â2) | â | 2,000 | 9â16 |
| 26 | May 13 | Braves | 5â3 | Adams (2â5) | Reulbach | Kantlehner (1) | â | 10â16 |
| 27 | May 15 | Braves | 8â7 | Harmon (3â3) | Rudolph | Mamaux (1) | â | 11â16 |
| 28 | May 18 | Phillies | 0â3 | Alexander | Kantlehner (2â5) | â | â | 11â17 |
| 29 | May 19 | Phillies | 4â2 | Mamaux (4â2) | McQuillan | â | â | 12â17 |
| 30 | May 20 | Phillies | 1â5 | Demaree | Adams (2â6) | â | â | 12â18 |
| 31 | May 23 | Robins | 0â6 | Pfeffer | Kantlehner (2â6) | â | â | 12â19 |
| 32 | May 24 | Robins | 2â3 (10) | Cheney | Harmon (3â4) | â | â | 12â20 |
| 33 | May 25 | Robins | 5â0 | Miller (1â1) | Dell | â | â | 13â20 |
| 34 | May 26 | @ Cardinals | 6â5 (11) | Mamaux (5â2) | Sallee | â | 2,000 | 14â20 |
| 35 | May 28 | @ Cardinals | 4â0 | Cooper (2â1) | Doak | â | â | 15â20 |
| 36 | May 28 | @ Cardinals | 4â1 (5) | Mamaux (6â2) | Meadows | â | â | 16â20 |
| 37 | May 29 | Reds | 1â6 | Mitchell | Jacobs (0â1) | â | â | 16â21 |
| 38 | May 30 | Reds | 9â8 | Cooper (3â1) | Schulz | â | â | 17â21 |
| 39 | May 31 | Reds | 2â5 (16) | Toney | Miller (1â2) | â | â | 17â22 |
|
June: 11â9 (Home: 4â2; Away: 7â7)
| # | Date | Opponent | Score | Win | Loss | Save | Attendance | Record |
| 40 | June 1 | Reds | 8â4 | Harmon (4â4) | Schneider | â | â | 18â22 |
| 41 | June 2 | @ Robins | 5â2 | Mamaux (7â2) | Appleton | â | â | 19â22 |
| 42 | June 5 | @ Robins | 2â3 | Dell | Miller (1â3) | â | 2,500 | 19â23 |
| 43 | June 6 | @ Giants | 3â2 | Mamaux (8â2) | Benton | â | 9,000 | 20â23 |
| 44 | June 12 | @ Phillies | 1â2 | Alexander | Mamaux (8â3) | â | â | 20â24 |
| 45 | June 13 | @ Phillies | 3â5 | Bender | Adams (2â7) | â | 4,000 | 20â25 |
| 46 | June 14 | @ Phillies | 2â3 (12) | Rixey | Jacobs (0â2) | â | â | 20â26 |
| 47 | June 15 | @ Braves | 2â1 | Mamaux (9â3) | Reulbach | â | â | 21â26 |
| 48 | June 16 | @ Braves | 0â2 | Hughes | Kantlehner (2â7) | â | â | 21â27 |
| 49 | June 20 | Cardinals | 6â10 (12) | Jasper | Miller (1â4) | Williams | â | 21â28 |
| 50 | June 22 | Cardinals | 8â4 | Jacobs (1â2) | Williams | â | â | 22â28 |
| 51 | June 23 | Cardinals | 7â8 | Jasper | Harmon (4â5) | Ames | â | 22â29 |
| 52 | June 24 | Cardinals | 4â3 | Mamaux (10â3) | Steele | â | â | 23â29 |
| 53 | June 24 | Cardinals | 5â2 | Miller (2â4) | Hall | â | â | 24â29 |
| 54 | June 25 | @ Cubs | 8â3 (12) | Cooper (4â1) | Vaughn | â | â | 25â29 |
| 55 | June 27 | @ Cubs | 0â1 | Prendergast | Cooper (4â2) | â | â | 25â30 |
| 56 | June 27 | @ Cubs | 4â10 | Seaton | Adams (2â8) | Prendergast | â | 25â31 |
| 57 | June 28 | @ Cubs | 3â2 | Mamaux (11â3) | Lavender | â | â | 26â31 |
| 58 | June 28 | @ Cubs | 3â2 (18) | Cooper (5â2) | McConnell | â | â | 27â31 |
| 59 | June 30 | @ Reds | 3â2 | Harmon (5â5) | Schneider | â | â | 28â31 |
|
July: 11â18 (Home: 8â10; Away: 3â8)
| # | Date | Opponent | Score | Win | Loss | Save | Attendance | Record |
| 60 | July 1 | @ Reds | 2â1 | Mamaux (12â3) | Knetzer | â | â | 29â31 |
| 61 | July 2 | @ Reds | 2â3 | Toney | Miller (2â5) | â | â | 29â32 |
| 62 | July 2 | @ Reds | 6â1 (5) | Kantlehner (3â7) | Dale | â | 6,000 | 30â32 |
| 63 | July 3 | Cubs | 2â3 | Seaton | Cooper (5â3) | Packard | â | 30â33 |
| 64 | July 4 | Cubs | 0â5 | Vaughn | Kantlehner (3â8) | â | â | 30â34 |
| 65 | July 4 | Cubs | 1â0 | Mamaux (13â3) | Prendergast | â | â | 31â34 |
| 66 | July 5 | Cubs | 3â4 | Hendrix | Miller (2â6) | Lavender | â | 31â35 |
| 67 | July 6 | Giants | 6â12 | Perritt | Cooper (5â4) | â | â | 31â36 |
| 68 | July 7 | Giants | 5â2 | Jacobs (2â2) | Anderson | â | â | 32â36 |
| 69 | July 8 | Giants | 4â6 | Benton | Mamaux (13â4) | â | â | 32â37 |
| 70 | July 10 | Giants | 7â1 | Miller (3â6) | Schauer | â | â | 33â37 |
| 71 | July 11 | Braves | 3â2 | Jacobs (3â2) | Barnes | â | â | 34â37 |
| 72 | July 12 | Braves | 5â6 | Barnes | Mamaux (13â5) | Hughes | â | 34â38 |
| 73 | July 14 | Braves | 0â3 | Ragan | Harmon (5â6) | â | 2,500 | 34â39 |
| 74 | July 15 | Phillies | 0â4 | Alexander | Jacobs (3â3) | â | â | 34â40 |
| 75 | July 15 | Phillies | 7â5 | Mamaux (14â5) | Chalmers | Kantlehner (2) | â | 35â40 |
| 76 | July 19 | Robins | 1â0 | Kantlehner (4â8) | Pfeffer | â | â | 36â40 |
| 77 | July 19 | Robins | 2â1 (14) | Miller (4â6) | Smith | â | â | 37â40 |
| 78 | July 22 | Robins | 1â7 | Pfeffer | Kantlehner (4â9) | â | â | 37â41 |
| 79 | July 22 | Robins | 2â3 (15) | Marquard | Miller (4â7) | â | â | 37â42 |
| 80 | July 24 | Phillies | 9â1 | Mamaux (15â5) | Demaree | â | â | 38â42 |
| 81 | July 26 | @ Phillies | 1â7 | Alexander | Adams (2â9) | â | â | 38â43 |
| 82 | July 26 | @ Phillies | 5â2 | Miller (5â7) | Rixey | â | 12,000 | 39â43 |
| 83 | July 27 | @ Phillies | 4â5 | Chalmers | Harmon (5â7) | â | 3,500 | 39â44 |
| 84 | July 28 | @ Phillies | 2â5 | Bender | Jacobs (3â4) | â | 4,500 | 39â45 |
| 85 | July 29 | @ Giants | 3â4 (11) | Perritt | Mamaux (15â6) | â | â | 39â46 |
| 86 | July 29 | @ Giants | 0â5 | Anderson | Kantlehner (4â10) | â | 25,000 | 39â47 |
| 87 | July 31 | @ Giants | 0â7 | Sallee | Miller (5â8) | â | â | 39â48 |
| 88 | July 31 | @ Giants | 0â7 | Tesreau | Jacobs (3â5) | â | â | 39â49 |
|
August: 16â15 (Home: 10â9; Away: 6â6)
| # | Date | Opponent | Score | Win | Loss | Save | Attendance | Record |
| 89 | August 1 | @ Giants | 4â3 (10) | Cooper (6â4) | Schupp | â | 5,000 | 40â49 |
| 90 | August 2 | @ Giants | 2â6 | Benton | Mamaux (15â7) | â | â | 40â50 |
| 91 | August 3 | @ Robins | 2â7 | Cheney | Miller (5â9) | â | 2,500 | 40â51 |
| 92 | August 4 | @ Robins | 0â2 | Smith | Harmon (5â8) | â | â | 40â52 |
| 93 | August 5 | @ Robins | 0â4 | Marquard | Cooper (6â5) | â | â | 40â53 |
| 94 | August 5 | @ Robins | 7â1 | Mamaux (16â7) | Pfeffer | â | â | 41â53 |
| 95 | August 11 | @ Braves | 2â1 | Miller (6â9) | Barnes | â | â | 42â53 |
| 96 | August 11 | @ Braves | 1â4 | Tyler | Mamaux (16â8) | â | 10,000 | 42â54 |
| 97 | August 12 | Cubs | 3â0 | Cooper (7â5) | Lavender | â | â | 43â54 |
| 98 | August 13 | @ Cardinals | 8â9 (11) | Ames | Kantlehner (4â11) | â | â | 43â55 |
| 99 | August 13 | @ Cardinals | 9â5 (5) | Mamaux (17â8) | Watson | â | â | 44â55 |
| 100 | August 15 | @ Cardinals | 1â0 | Harmon (6â8) | Meadows | â | â | 45â55 |
| 101 | August 15 | @ Cardinals | 2â1 | Cooper (8â5) | Ames | â | â | 46â55 |
| 102 | August 17 | Robins | 1â5 | Pfeffer | Mamaux (17â9) | â | â | 46â56 |
| 103 | August 18 | Robins | 0â6 | Cheney | Harmon (6â9) | â | â | 46â57 |
| 104 | August 19 | Robins | 2â1 (10) | Cooper (9â5) | Smith | â | â | 47â57 |
| 105 | August 19 | Robins | 0â1 | Marquard | Kantlehner (4â12) | â | â | 47â58 |
| 106 | August 21 | Phillies | 6â3 | Jacobs (4â5) | Alexander | â | â | 48â58 |
| 107 | August 21 | Phillies | 2â1 | Evans (1â0) | Demaree | â | â | 49â58 |
| 108 | August 22 | Phillies | 2â6 | Mayer | Harmon (6â10) | McQuillan | â | 49â59 |
| 109 | August 22 | Phillies | 9â7 | Cooper (10â5) | Bender | â | â | 50â59 |
| 110 | August 23 | Phillies | 2â1 (16) | Evans (2â0) | Rixey | â | 1,000 | 51â59 |
| 111 | August 24 | Giants | 10â1 | Jacobs (5â5) | Tesreau | â | â | 52â59 |
| 112 | August 25 | Giants | 2â6 (11) | Tesreau | Harmon (6â11) | â | 3,000 | 52â60 |
| 113 | August 26 | Giants | 1â1 (14) | | | â | â | 52â60 |
| 114 | August 28 | Braves | 5â1 | Mamaux (18â9) | Rudolph | â | â | 53â60 |
| 115 | August 28 | Braves | 2â8 (7) | Allen | Kantlehner (4â13) | â | 5,000 | 53â61 |
| 116 | August 29 | Braves | 1â6 | Tyler | Jacobs (5â6) | â | â | 53â62 |
| 117 | August 29 | Braves | 5â9 | Hughes | Kantlehner (4â14) | â | 7,000 | 53â63 |
| 118 | August 30 | Braves | 0â1 | Rudolph | Cooper (10â6) | â | â | 53â64 |
| 119 | August 30 | Braves | 7â6 | Jacobs (6â6) | Allen | Cooper (1) | 5,000 | 54â64 |
| 120 | August 31 | Braves | 3â2 (8) | Mamaux (19â9) | Nehf | â | 2,000 | 55â64 |
|
September: 10â24 (Home: 6â6; Away: 4â18)
| # | Date | Opponent | Score | Win | Loss | Save | Attendance | Record |
| 121 | September 1 | Reds | 3â6 | Toney | Jacobs (6â7) | â | â | 55â65 |
| 122 | September 2 | Reds | 4â3 | Harmon (7â11) | Knetzer | â | â | 56â65 |
| 123 | September 2 | Reds | 2â7 | Moseley | Evans (2â1) | Schulz | 10,000 | 56â66 |
| 124 | September 3 | @ Reds | 6â7 | Mitchell | Mamaux (19â10) | â | â | 56â67 |
| 125 | September 4 | Cardinals | 7â0 | Miller (7â9) | Meadows | â | 5,000 | 57â67 |
| 126 | September 4 | Cardinals | 2â0 | Cooper (11â6) | Watson | â | 12,000 | 58â67 |
| 127 | September 6 | Cardinals | 3â2 | Kantlehner (5â14) | Steele | â | â | 59â67 |
| 128 | September 6 | Cardinals | 6â3 | Harmon (8â11) | Ames | â | 3,500 | 60â67 |
| 129 | September 7 | Cubs | 5â4 | Mamaux (20â10) | Packard | Cooper (2) | â | 61â67 |
| 130 | September 9 | Cubs | 0â3 | Vaughn | Kantlehner (5â15) | â | â | 61â68 |
| 131 | September 9 | Cubs | 0â2 | Lavender | Cooper (11â7) | â | 12,000 | 61â69 |
| 132 | September 10 | @ Cubs | 8â7 | Grimes (1â0) | Prendergast | Mamaux (2) | â | 62â69 |
| 133 | September 12 | @ Robins | 0â6 | Pfeffer | Evans (2â2) | â | â | 62â70 |
| 134 | September 12 | @ Robins | 2â1 | Mamaux (21â10) | Coombs | â | 10,000 | 63â70 |
| 135 | September 13 | @ Robins | 6â3 | Cooper (12â7) | Smith | â | â | 64â70 |
| 136 | September 14 | @ Robins | 2â3 | Cheney | Grimes (1â1) | â | â | 64â71 |
| 137 | September 15 | @ Robins | 1â8 (5) | Marquard | Jacobs (6â8) | â | â | 64â72 |
| 138 | September 16 | @ Giants | 2â8 | Benton | Mamaux (21â11) | â | â | 64â73 |
| 139 | September 16 | @ Giants | 3â4 | Tesreau | Cooper (12â8) | â | â | 64â74 |
| 140 | September 18 | @ Giants | 0â2 | Schupp | Miller (7â10) | â | â | 64â75 |
| 141 | September 18 | @ Giants | 1â1 (8) | | | â | â | 64â75 |
| 142 | September 19 | @ Giants | 2â9 | Benton | Jacobs (6â9) | â | â | 64â76 |
| 143 | September 19 | @ Giants | 1â5 | Tesreau | Evans (2â3) | â | â | 64â77 |
| 144 | September 20 | @ Phillies | 0â7 | Demaree | Cooper (12â9) | â | â | 64â78 |
| 145 | September 20 | @ Phillies | 2â3 | Demaree | Mamaux (21â12) | â | â | 64â79 |
| 146 | September 21 | @ Phillies | 8â3 | Grimes (2â1) | Rixey | â | â | 65â79 |
| 147 | September 22 | @ Phillies | 4â7 | Mayer | Evans (2â4) | â | â | 65â80 |
| 148 | September 23 | @ Braves | 2â4 | Rudolph | Mamaux (21â13) | â | â | 65â81 |
| 149 | September 23 | @ Braves | 1â1 (13) | | | â | â | 65â81 |
| 150 | September 25 | @ Braves | 0â5 | Tyler | Grimes (2â2) | â | â | 65â82 |
| 151 | September 25 | @ Braves | 2â3 | Reulbach | Mamaux (21â14) | â | â | 65â83 |
| 152 | September 26 | @ Braves | 0â3 | Nehf | Evans (2â5) | â | â | 65â84 |
| 153 | September 26 | @ Braves | 1â2 | Allen | Jacobs (6â10) | â | â | 65â85 |
| 154 | September 27 | @ Braves | 0â1 | Tyler | Cooper (12â10) | â | â | 65â86 |
| 155 | September 30 | Reds | 4â5 | Mitchell | Mamaux (21â15) | â | â | 65â87 |
|
October: 0â1 (Home: 0â0; Away: 0â1)
| # | Date | Opponent | Score | Win | Loss | Save | Attendance | Record |
| 157 | October 1 | @ Reds | 0â4 | Toney | Cooper (12â11) | â | â | 65â89 |
|
Legend: = Win = Loss = Tie Bold = Pirates team member |