1957 Game Log[5] Overall Record: 77–77 |
| # | Date | Opponent | Score | Win | Loss | Save | Attendance | Record |
| 1 | April 16 | Dodgers | 6–7 (12) | Clem Labine (1–0) | Robin Roberts (0–1) | None | 37,667 | 0–1 |
| 2 | April 18 | @ Giants | 2–6 | Rubén Gómez (1–0) | Curt Simmons (0–1) | None | 8,585 | 0–2 |
| 3 | April 20 | @ Giants | 6–5 | Harvey Haddix (1–0) | Al Worthington (0–1) | Bob Miller (1) | 8,875 | 1–2 |
| 4 | April 21 (1) | @ Giants | 1–2 | Johnny Antonelli (1–1) | Robin Roberts (0–2) | None | see 2nd game | 1–3 |
| 5 | April 21 (2) | @ Giants | 8–5 | Jack Sanford (1–0) | Curt Barclay (0–1) | Don Cardwell (1) | 14,230 | 2–3 |
| 6 | April 22 | @ Dodgers | 1–5 | Roger Craig (1–0) | Jim Hearn (0–1) | Clem Labine (2) | 11,629 | 2–4 |
| 7 | April 24 | Pirates | 8–5 | Curt Simmons (1–1) | Bob Friend (1–2) | Bob Miller (2) | 15,849 | 3–4 |
| 8 | April 26 | Giants | 5–0 | Don Cardwell (1–0) | Johnny Antonelli (1–2) | None | 14,118 | 4–4 |
| 9 | April 27 | Giants | 2–10 | Rubén Gómez (3–0) | Robin Roberts (0–3) | None | 7,577 | 4–5 |
| 10 | April 28 (1) | Giants | 11–2 | Jack Sanford (2–0) | Al Worthington (0–2) | Bob Miller (3) | see 2nd game | 5–5 |
| 11 | April 28 (2) | Giants | 7–8[a] | Curt Barclay (1–2) | Jack Meyer (0–1) | Marv Grissom (1) | 19,482 | 5–6 |
| 12 | April 30 | Redlegs | 3–6 | Brooks Lawrence (2–1) | Harvey Haddix (1–1) | None | 14,851 | 5–7 |
|
| # | Date | Opponent | Score | Win | Loss | Save | Attendance | Record |
| 13 | May 1 | Redlegs | 6–8 (16) | Warren Hacker (1–1) | Turk Farrell (0–1) | Hersh Freeman (1) | 8,606 | 5–8 |
| 14 | May 2 | Cubs | 4–2 | Robin Roberts (1–3) | Dick Drott (0–3) | None | 4,591 | 6–8 |
| 15 | May 3 | Cubs | 9–6 | Turk Farrell (1–1) | Jackie Collum (1–1) | Jim Hearn (1) | 6,160 | 7–8 |
| 16 | May 4 | Cubs | 5–2 | Jack Sanford (3–0) | Jim Brosnan (0–1) | None | 3,283 | 8–8 |
| 17 | May 5 (1) | Cardinals | 4–8 | Lloyd Merritt (1–0) | Bob Miller (0–1) | None | see 2nd game | 8–9 |
| 18 | May 5 (2) | Cardinals | 0–2 | Sam Jones (2–0) | Harvey Haddix (1–2) | None | 27,213 | 8–10 |
| 19 | May 7 | Braves | 8–4 | Robin Roberts (2–3) | Warren Spahn (4–1) | None | 20,421 | 9–10 |
| 20 | May 8 | Braves | 2–1 | Don Cardwell (2–0) | Gene Conley (0–1) | None | 17,739 | 10–10 |
| 21 | May 10 | @ Pirates | 3–1 | Jack Sanford (4–0) | Ron Kline (0–4) | None | 10,027 | 11–10 |
| 22 | May 11 | @ Pirates | 7–2 | Harvey Haddix (2–2) | Bob Friend (2–3) | None | 4,994 | 12–10 |
| 23 | May 12 (1) | @ Pirates | 6–2 | Curt Simmons (2–1) | Luis Arroyo (0–4) | Bob Miller (4) | see 2nd game | 13–10 |
| 24 | May 12 (2) | @ Pirates | 1–6 | Vern Law (2–1) | Robin Roberts (2–4) | None | 10,457 | 13–11 |
| 25 | May 14 | @ Redlegs | 10–8 | Turk Farrell (2–1) | Raúl Sánchez (2–1) | Robin Roberts (1) | 9,829 | 14–11 |
| 26 | May 15 | @ Redlegs | 2–7 | Brooks Lawrence (4–1) | Jack Sanford (4–1) | None | 12,442 | 14–12 |
| 27 | May 16 | @ Cardinals | 0–5 | Lindy McDaniel (2–1) | Harvey Haddix (2–3) | None | 5,377 | 14–13 |
| 28 | May 17 | @ Cardinals | 5–3 | Robin Roberts (3–4) | Sam Jones (2–2) | None | 9,367 | 15–13 |
| 29 | May 18 | @ Cardinals | 7–5 | Curt Simmons (3–1) | Lloyd Merritt (1–1) | None | 5,232 | 16–13 |
| – | May 19 (1) | @ Cubs | Postponed (rain);[6] Makeup: September 17 |
| – | May 19 (2) | @ Cubs | Postponed (rain);[6] Makeup: September 18 |
| 30 | May 21 | @ Braves | 1–1 (5)[b] | None | None | None | 15,936 | 16–13–1 |
| 31 | May 22 | @ Braves | 3–4 (13) | Juan Pizarro (2–2) | Robin Roberts (3–5) | None | 21,775 | 16–14–1 |
| 32 | May 24 | Pirates | 7–3 | Jack Sanford (5–1) | Bob Friend (3–4) | Turk Farrell (1) | 17,340 | 17–14–1 |
| 33 | May 25 | Pirates | 8–6 | Harvey Haddix (3–3) | Ron Kline (0–6) | Turk Farrell (2) | 6,445 | 18–14–1 |
| 34 | May 26 (1) | Pirates | 5–13 | Roy Face (1–3) | Curt Simmons (3–2) | None | see 2nd game | 18–15–1 |
| 35 | May 26 (2) | Pirates | 6–3 | Don Cardwell (3–0) | Luis Arroyo (1–5) | None | 13,557 | 19–15–1 |
| 36 | May 27 | Dodgers | 1–5 | Don Drysdale (4–1) | Robin Roberts (3–6) | None | 20,673 | 19–16–1 |
| 37 | May 28 | @ Giants | 16–6 | Bob Miller (1–1) | Johnny Antonelli (3–6) | None | 4,977 | 20–16–1 |
| 38 | May 29 | @ Giants | 7–5 (10) | Robin Roberts (4–6) | Marv Grissom (0–2) | None | 2,216 | 21–16–1 |
| 39 | May 30 (1) | @ Giants | 2–1 (10) | Curt Simmons (4–2) | Rubén Gómez (6–3) | None | see 2nd game | 22–16–1 |
| 40 | May 30 (2) | @ Giants | 1–8 | Curt Barclay (3–3) | Don Cardwell (3–1) | None | 19,887 | 22–17–1 |
| 41 | May 31 | Dodgers | 2–1 | Robin Roberts (5–6) | Don Drysdale (4–2) | None | 24,381 | 23–17–1 |
|
| # | Date | Opponent | Score | Win | Loss | Save | Attendance | Record |
| 42 | June 1 | Dodgers | 3–0 | Jack Sanford (6–1) | Roger Craig (1–2) | None | 30,621 | 24–17–1 |
| 43 | June 2 | Dodgers | 5–3 | Turk Farrell (3–1) | Don Newcombe (4–5) | None | 20,259 | 25–17–1 |
| 44 | June 3 | Dodgers | 0–4 | Johnny Podres (5–2) | Don Cardwell (3–2) | None | 18,218 | 25–18–1 |
| 45 | June 4 | Redlegs | 3–1 | Harvey Haddix (4–3) | Brooks Lawrence (4–3) | None | 20,759 | 26–18–1 |
| 46 | June 5 | Redlegs | 2–4 (11) | Johnny Klippstein (2–4) | Turk Farrell (3–2) | None | 15,771 | 26–19–1 |
| 47 | June 6 | Redlegs | 6–2 | Robin Roberts (6–6) | Don Gross (4–2) | None | 27,307 | 27–19–1 |
| 48 | June 7 | Cubs | 1–0 | Jack Sanford (7–1) | Dave Hillman (0–2) | None | 12,845 | 28–19–1 |
| – | June 8 | Cubs | Postponed (rain);[7] Makeup: July 11 as a traditional double-header |
| 49 | June 9 (1) | Cubs | 3–7 | Dick Drott (4–6) | Robin Roberts (6–7) | Turk Lown (3) | see 2nd game | 28–20–1 |
| 50 | June 9 (2) | Cubs | 4–4[c] | None | None | None | 17,375 | 28–20–2 |
| 51 | June 11 | Cardinals | 2–5 | Murry Dickson (3–2) | Curt Simmons (4–3) | None | 23,888 | 28–21–2 |
| 52 | June 12 | Cardinals | 0–4 | Larry Jackson (8–2) | Robin Roberts (6–8) | None | 22,749 | 28–22–2 |
| 53 | June 13 | Cardinals | 8–1 | Jack Sanford (8–1) | Vinegar Bend Mizell (1–4) | None | 22,509 | 29–22–2 |
| 54 | June 14 | Braves | 2–10 | Warren Spahn (7–3) | Don Cardwell (3–3) | None | 29,465 | 29–23–2 |
| 55 | June 15 | Braves | 2–7 | Bob Buhl (6–2) | Harvey Haddix (4–4) | None | 12,178 | 29–24–2 |
| 56 | June 16 (1) | Braves | 2–3 | Juan Pizarro (3–5) | Bob Miller (1–2) | None | see 2nd game | 29–25–2 |
| 57 | June 16 (2) | Braves | 1–0 | Curt Simmons (5–3) | Lew Burdette (5–3) | None | 30,520 | 30–25–2 |
| 58 | June 18 | @ Cubs | 7–6 | Jim Hearn (1–1) | Dave Hillman (0–4) | None | 6,092 | 31–25–2 |
| 59 | June 19 (1) | @ Cubs | 0–9 | Dick Drott (6–6) | Don Cardwell (3–4) | None | see 2nd game | 31–26–2 |
| 60 | June 19 (2) | @ Cubs | 3–4 | Moe Drabowsky (4–5) | Bob Miller (1–3) | Turk Lown (5) | 10,939 | 31–27–2 |
| 61 | June 20 | @ Cubs | 7–2 | Harvey Haddix (5–4) | Don Kaiser (2–5) | None | 5,210 | 32–27–2 |
| 62 | June 21 | @ Braves | 6–1 | Curt Simmons (6–3) | Lew Burdette (5–4) | None | 33,533 | 33–27–2 |
| 63 | June 22 | @ Braves | 4–2 | Jack Sanford (9–1) | Bob Trowbridge (2–1) | None | 25,498 | 34–27–2 |
| 64 | June 23 (1) | @ Braves | 6–7 | Bob Buhl (8–2) | Robin Roberts (6–9) | None | see 2nd game | 34–28–2 |
| 65 | June 23 (2) | @ Braves | 3–7 | Taylor Phillips (3–2) | Seth Morehead (0–1) | Bob Trowbridge (1) | 36,037 | 34–29–2 |
| 66 | June 24 | @ Braves | 10–4 | Harvey Haddix (6–4) | Warren Spahn (7–5) | Jim Hearn (2) | 15,600 | 35–29–2 |
| 67 | June 26 | @ Cardinals | 11–3 | Curt Simmons (7–3) | Lindy McDaniel (7–4) | None | 14,192 | 36–29–2 |
| 68 | June 27 | @ Cardinals | 4–6 | Von McDaniel (3–0) | Jack Sanford (9–2) | Hoyt Wilhelm (7) | 25,133 | 36–30–2 |
| 69 | June 28 | @ Redlegs | 1–7 | Hal Jeffcoat (7–5) | Don Cardwell (3–5) | None | 16,848 | 36–31–2 |
| 70 | June 29 | @ Redlegs | 3–8 | Tom Acker (9–3) | Robin Roberts (6–10) | None | 10,290 | 36–32–2 |
| 71 | June 30 (1) | @ Redlegs | 1–6 | Brooks Lawrence (9–4) | Curt Simmons (7–4) | None | see 2nd game | 36–33–2 |
| 72 | June 30 (2) | @ Redlegs | 2–6 | Johnny Klippstein (3–7) | Harvey Haddix (6–5) | Brooks Lawrence (1) | 32,584 | 36–34–2 |
|
| # | Date | Opponent | Score | Win | Loss | Save | Attendance | Record |
| 73 | July 1 | @ Pirates | 5–4 | Jim Hearn (2–1) | Bob Smith (0–2) | Seth Morehead (1) | 14,680 | 37–34–2 |
| 74 | July 4 (1) | Giants | 2–1 | Harvey Haddix (7–5) | Rubén Gómez (10–6) | None | see 2nd game | 38–34–2 |
| 75 | July 4 (2) | Giants | 6–2 | Curt Simmons (8–4) | Stu Miller (3–4) | Turk Farrell (3) | 30,442 | 39–34–2 |
| 76 | July 5 | @ Dodgers | 5–6 | Roger Craig (3–5) | Robin Roberts (6–11) | Johnny Podres (1) | 13,324 | 39–35–2 |
| 77 | July 6 | @ Dodgers | 9–4 | Jack Sanford (10–2) | Don Drysdale (6–6) | None | 8,939 | 40–35–2 |
| 78 | July 7 (1) | @ Dodgers | 2–1 | Warren Hacker (4–2) | Sal Maglie (3–2) | Turk Farrell (4) | see 2nd game | 41–35–2 |
| 79 | July 7 (2) | @ Dodgers | 5–3 | Jim Hearn (3–1) | Clem Labine (3–5) | Turk Farrell (5) | 16,805 | 42–35–2 |
| – | July 9 | 1957 Major League Baseball All-Star Game at Sportsman's Park in St. Louis |
| 80 | July 11 (1) | Cubs | 1–0 (11) | Harvey Haddix (8–5) | Bob Rush (1–8) | None | see 2nd game | 43–35–2 |
| 81 | July 11 (2) | Cubs | 3–1 | Jack Sanford (11–2) | Don Elston (2–1) | None | 25,897 | 44–35–2 |
| 82 | July 12 | Cubs | 2–5 | Jim Brosnan (1–3) | Robin Roberts (6–12) | None | 11,526 | 44–36–2 |
| 83 | July 13 | Cubs | 5–2 | Warren Hacker (5–2) | Dick Drott (8–8) | Turk Farrell (6) | 4,541 | 45–36–2 |
| 84 | July 14 (1) | Cardinals | 6–2 | Curt Simmons (9–4) | Von McDaniel (4–1) | None | see 2nd game | 46–36–2 |
| 85 | July 14 (2) | Cardinals | 11–4 | Jim Hearn (4–1) | Larry Jackson (10–5) | None | 26,451 | 47–36–2 |
| 86 | July 15 | Cardinals | 6–2 | Jack Sanford (12–2) | Vinegar Bend Mizell (3–7) | None | 33,906 | 48–36–2 |
| 87 | July 16 | Braves | 2–6 | Warren Spahn (10–7) | Harvey Haddix (8–6) | None | 24,846 | 48–37–2 |
| 88 | July 17 | Braves | 3–10[d] | Lew Burdette (8–6) | Jack Meyer (0–2) | Don McMahon (3) | 24,596 | 48–38–2 |
| 89 | July 18 | Braves | 2–4 | Bob Buhl (10–6) | Curt Simmons (9–5) | Don McMahon (4) | 24,385 | 48–39–2 |
| 90 | July 19 | Redlegs | 2–7 | Joe Nuxhall (4–5) | Jack Sanford (12–3) | None | 27,147 | 48–40–2 |
| 91 | July 20 | Redlegs | 7–5 | Turk Farrell (4–2) | Don Gross (4–6) | None | 11,574 | 49–40–2 |
| 92 | July 21 (1) | Redlegs | 2–4 | Brooks Lawrence (11–5) | Robin Roberts (6–13) | Hersh Freeman (7) | see 2nd game | 49–41–2 |
| 93 | July 21 (2) | Redlegs | 4–6 | Art Fowler (1–0) | Harvey Haddix (8–7) | Johnny Klippstein (1) | 26,787 | 49–42–2 |
| 94 | July 23 | @ Braves | 0–1 | Bob Buhl (11–6) | Curt Simmons (9–6) | None | 34,243 | 49–43–2 |
| 95 | July 24 | @ Braves | 3–1 | Jack Sanford (13–3) | Gene Conley (3–5) | None | 32,412 | 50–43–2 |
| 96 | July 25 | @ Braves | 5–3 | Robin Roberts (7–13) | Warren Spahn (10–8) | Turk Farrell (7) | 28,545 | 51–43–2 |
| 97 | July 26 | @ Cubs | 3–1 (10) | Warren Hacker (6–2) | Bob Rush (1–11) | Turk Farrell (8) | 8,957 | 52–43–2 |
| 98 | July 27 | @ Cubs | 1–6 | Jim Brosnan (2–4) | Harvey Haddix (8–8) | None | 11,323 | 52–44–2 |
| 99 | July 28 (1) | @ Cubs | 3–2 | Curt Simmons (10–6) | Tom Poholsky (1–6) | Turk Farrell (9) | see 2nd game | 53–44–2 |
| 100 | July 28 (2) | @ Cubs | 7–1 | Jack Sanford (14–3) | Dick Drott (9–9) | None | 20,512 | 54–44–2 |
| 101 | July 29 | @ Cubs | 6–0 | Robin Roberts (8–13) | Don Elston (3–4) | None | 3,637 | 55–44–2 |
| 102 | July 30 | @ Redlegs | 8–5 | Bob Miller (2–3) | Hersh Freeman (5–2) | None | 15,813 | 56–44–2 |
| 103 | July 31 | @ Redlegs | 5–6 (11) | Art Fowler (3–0) | Bob Miller (2–4) | None | 12,721 | 56–45–2 |
|
| # | Date | Opponent | Score | Win | Loss | Save | Attendance | Record |
| 104 | August 1 | @ Redlegs | 3–4 | Johnny Klippstein (5–10) | Curt Simmons (10–7) | Tom Acker (4) | 11,720 | 56–46–2 |
| 105 | August 2 | @ Cardinals | 4–5 (10) | Willard Schmidt (10–1) | Bob Miller (2–5) | None | 21,898 | 56–47–2 |
| 106 | August 3 | @ Cardinals | 1–3 | Von McDaniel (6–2) | Robin Roberts (8–14) | Billy Muffett (1) | 18,955 | 56–48–2 |
| 107 | August 4 (1) | @ Cardinals | 5–4 (12) | Harvey Haddix (9–8) | Larry Jackson (12–6) | None | see 2nd game | 57–48–2 |
| 108 | August 4 (2) | @ Cardinals | 1–4 | Lindy McDaniel (10–6) | Warren Hacker (6–3) | None | 29,098 | 57–49–2 |
| 109 | August 6 | @ Pirates | 3–5 | Ron Kline (3–15) | Jack Sanford (14–4) | None | 11,136 | 57–50–2 |
| 110 | August 8 | @ Pirates | 6–3 | Curt Simmons (11–7) | Vern Law (7–7) | Bob Miller (5) | 5,238 | 58–50–2 |
| 111 | August 9 | @ Giants | 2–6 | Ray Crone (5–6) | Robin Roberts (8–15) | None | 6,247 | 58–51–2 |
| – | August 10 | @ Giants | Postponed (rain);[8] Makeup: August 11 as a traditional double-header |
| 112 | August 11 (1) | @ Giants | 0–5 | Curt Barclay (7–7) | Harvey Haddix (9–9) | None | see 2nd game | 58–52–2 |
| 113 | August 11 (2) | @ Giants | 2–0 | Jack Sanford (15–4) | Johnny Antonelli (11–12) | None | 13,880 | 59–52–2 |
| 114 | August 13 | Pirates | 0–6 | Bob Friend (8–15) | Warren Hacker (6–4) | None | 14,129 | 59–53–2 |
| 115 | August 14 | Pirates | 3–10 | Vern Law (9–7) | Curt Simmons (11–8) | None | 8,641 | 59–54–2 |
| 116 | August 16 | Giants | 1–2 | Stu Miller (5–8) | Robin Roberts (8–16) | None | 16,733 | 59–55–2 |
| 117 | August 17 | Giants | 3–1 | Jack Sanford (16–4) | Rubén Gómez (13–10) | None | 7,929 | 60–55–2 |
| 118 | August 18 (1) | Giants | 4–5 | Mike McCormick (2–0) | Warren Hacker (6–5) | Marv Grissom (8) | see 2nd game | 60–56–2 |
| 119 | August 18 (2) | Giants | 0–1 | Al Worthington (8–8) | Harvey Haddix (9–10) | None | 14,591 | 60–57–2 |
| 120 | August 20 (1) | Cubs | 2–1 (10) | Turk Farrell (5–2) | Moe Drabowsky (9–11) | None | see 2nd game | 61–57–2 |
| 121 | August 20 (2) | Cubs | 2–5 | Don Elston (4–5) | Robin Roberts (8–17) | None | 15,129 | 61–58–2 |
| 122 | August 22 | Cardinals | 5–6 | Larry Jackson (13–6) | Jack Sanford (16–5) | Billy Muffett (3) | 21,947 | 61–59–2 |
| 123 | August 23 | Cardinals | 3–2 | Harvey Haddix (10–10) | Vinegar Bend Mizell (5–10) | None | 20,284 | 62–59–2 |
| 124 | August 24 | Cardinals | 2–5 | Herm Wehmeier (6–6) | Curt Simmons (11–9) | None | 11,049 | 62–60–2 |
| 125 | August 25 | Braves | 3–7 | Warren Spahn (16–8) | Robin Roberts (8–18) | None | 14,051 | 62–61–2 |
| 126 | August 26 | Braves | 4–3 | Turk Farrell (6–2) | Ernie Johnson (6–2) | None | 21,397 | 63–61–2 |
| 127 | August 27 | Redlegs | 2–5 | Joe Nuxhall (8–7) | Don Cardwell (3–6) | None | 15,520 | 63–62–2 |
| 128 | August 28 | Redlegs | 5–6 | Brooks Lawrence (12–11) | Curt Simmons (11–10) | Johnny Klippstein (2) | 15,134 | 63–63–2 |
| 129 | August 30 | Pirates | 4–3 | Jack Sanford (17–5) | Vern Law (10–8) | None | 8,157 | 64–63–2 |
| 130 | August 31 | Pirates | 7–1 | Don Cardwell (4–6) | Bob Friend (10–17) | None | 5,141 | 65–63–2 |
|
| # | Date | Opponent | Score | Win | Loss | Save | Attendance | Record |
| 131 | September 1 (1) | Pirates | 11–3 | Robin Roberts (9–18) | Bob Purkey (10–13) | None | see 2nd game | 66–63–2 |
| 132 | September 1 (2) | Pirates | 3–6 | Whammy Douglas (2–2) | Curt Simmons (11–11) | Roy Face (7) | 11,294 | 66–64–2 |
| 133 | September 2 (1) | @ Dodgers | 10–4 | Warren Hacker (7–5) | Danny McDevitt (6–2) | None | see 2nd game | 67–64–2 |
| 134 | September 2 (2) | @ Dodgers | 7–4 | Jim Hearn (5–1) | Roger Craig (5–8) | None | 18,895 | 68–64–2 |
| 135 | September 3 | @ Dodgers | 3–2 (12) | Turk Farrell (7–2) | Don Drysdale (14–8) | Bob Miller (6) | 10,190 | 69–64–2 |
| 136 | September 4 | Dodgers | 3–12 | Don Newcombe (11–11) | Don Cardwell (4–7) | Ed Roebuck (6) | 17,615 | 69–65–2 |
| 137 | September 5 | Dodgers | 1–3 | Carl Erskine (4–2) | Robin Roberts (9–19) | Ed Roebuck (7) | 18,087 | 69–66–2 |
| 138 | September 6 | @ Pirates | 2–3 | Ron Kline (7–15) | Harvey Haddix (10–11) | None | 6,915 | 69–67–2 |
| 139 | September 7 | @ Pirates | 3–6 | Red Swanson (3–2) | Jack Sanford (17–6) | Roy Face (9) | 4,612 | 69–68–2 |
| 140 | September 8 (1) | @ Pirates | 7–4 | Turk Farrell (8–2) | Bob Purkey (10–14) | Robin Roberts (2) | see 2nd game | 70–68–2 |
| 141 | September 8 (2) | @ Pirates | 2–6 | Bob Smith (1–3) | Warren Hacker (7–6) | None | 12,021 | 70–69–2 |
| 142 | September 10 | @ Cardinals | 3–4 (14) | Lindy McDaniel (14–8) | Robin Roberts (9–20) | None | 10,997 | 70–70–2 |
| 143 | September 11 | @ Cardinals | 6–14 | Herm Wehmeier (9–6) | Harvey Haddix (10–12) | Hoyt Wilhelm (11) | 10,674 | 70–71–2 |
| 144 | September 13 | @ Redlegs | 7–8 | Tom Acker (10–5) | Jack Sanford (17–7) | Johnny Klippstein (3) | 6,805 | 70–72–2 |
| 145 | September 14 | @ Redlegs | 5–0 | Robin Roberts (10–20) | Brooks Lawrence (15–12) | None | 4,527 | 71–72–2 |
| 146 | September 15 | @ Braves | 3–2 (10) | Turk Farrell (9–2) | Warren Spahn (19–10) | None | 34,920 | 72–72–2 |
| 147 | September 16 | @ Braves | 1–5 | Bob Buhl (17–6) | Harvey Haddix (10–13) | None | 20,929 | 72–73–2 |
| 148 | September 17 | @ Cubs | 1–7 | Moe Drabowsky (11–14) | Jack Sanford (17–8) | None | 1,727 | 72–74–2 |
| 149 | September 18 | @ Cubs | 4–6 | Dick Drott (15–11) | Robin Roberts (10–21) | Don Elston (6) | 2,094 | 72–75–2 |
| 150 | September 20 | @ Dodgers | 3–2 | Turk Farrell (10–2) | Carl Erskine (5–3) | Jim Hearn (3) | 6,749 | 73–75–2 |
| 151 | September 21 | @ Dodgers | 3–2 | Jack Sanford (18–8) | Johnny Podres (12–9) | Turk Farrell (10) | 5,118 | 74–75–2 |
| 152 | September 22 | @ Dodgers | 3–7 | Don Drysdale (17–9) | Robin Roberts (10–22) | None | 6,662 | 74–76–2 |
| 153 | September 24 | Giants | 5–0 | Curt Simmons (12–11) | Curt Barclay (9–9) | None | 7,019 | 75–76–2 |
| 154 | September 27 | Dodgers | 3–2 | Jack Sanford (19–8) | Bill Harris (0–1) | None | 11,595 | 76–76–2 |
| 155 | September 28 | Dodgers | 4–8 | Ed Roebuck (8–2) | Don Cardwell (4–8) | Johnny Podres (3) | 5,797 | 76–77–2 |
| 156 | September 29 | Dodgers | 2–1 | Seth Morehead (1–1) | Roger Craig (6–9) | None | 9,886 | 77–77–2 |
|
- ^[a]The second game on April 28 was suspended (Sunday curfew[9][10]) in the bottom of the seventh inning with the score 7–8 and was completed August 16, 1957.[11][12]
- ^[b]The May 21 game was called after 51⁄2 innings (reduced to 5 innings[13]) with the score tied 1–1.[14][15] It was replayed from the start on June 24, 1957.
- ^[c]The second game on June 9 was suspended (Sunday curfew[16][17]) in the top of the tenth inning[18] with the score 4–4.[19] Because at least nine innings had been completed, the game was replayed from the beginning[20] on August 20, 1957.
- ^[d]The July 17 game was protested by the Phillies between the first and second innings.[21][22][23][24][25] The protest was later denied.[26]
|