The Hamilton JournalNews said "the game definitely shows promise. If you plan to simply spend one evening by playing a game with a friend, ASG ranks high on the basis of enjoyment."[2]
Ellis Simpson reviewed ASG Baseball for Games International magazine, and gave it 4 stars out of 5, and stated that "Like many baseball games there is much more work and research than a few pieces of paper can hold. The man hours involved in this project must have been enormous. The end result is a game that baseball fans and sports gamers and will love. No ifs, or buts."[1]