Aberdyfi won the Welsh Amateur Cup in 1935, beating Aberystwyth Town 2–1 in the final.[1] Aberdyfi Town also won the 1937–38 Cambrian Coast Football League.[2] However this club folded in the 1960s.[3]
They were reformed in 1996, joining the Aberystwyth League.[4] In their first season they won the Division Two title, to earn promotion to Division One.[5] In 2010–11 they were Aberystwyth League champions, earning promotion to the Mid Wales Football League Division Two.[6]
In their first Mid Wales League season they finished 11th out of 16 teams, before finishing last of out of 13 in their second season.[7] They then returned to the Aberystwyth League.[8] In 2011–12 they also played in the Welsh Cup, losing in the first qualifying round against Barmouth & Dyffryn United.[9]
In 2017 they were relegated to Division Two of the Aberystwyth League, after finishing bottom of Division One.[10] In 2019 they were promoted back to Division One.[11][12]
The club folded in 2022.[13]