Akimi Village received mixed reviews from critics, achieving a Metacritic score of 69 out of 100.[4] Maurice Tan of Destructoid gave a positive review of the game, describing it as "a fantastic little game" and comparing it favourably to Ninjabee's previous games, A Kingdom for Keflings and A World for Keflings. Tan also noted that the game's mechanics subtly portrayed the player character as a "slaver overlord".[5] Tim Leigh, writing in Console Monster, also gave a positive review, describing it as "very fun" and praising the game's visuals.[9]
Ian MacKinnon of Gamers Daily gave a mixed review, praising it as "enjoyable" but also stating that it had very little replay value.[8] Neilie Johnson of IGN also gave a mixed review, writing that it was "fun for the first hour or two", but criticising it as "long on repetition and short on reward", and stating that the building mechanics were not improved from the earlier Keflings games.[7]