On January 19, 1941, Neely and her husband attended the Inaugural Gala at Constitution Hall in Washington, D.C. as part of a delegation of thirty-two state executives and state representatives who were celebrating the third inauguration of U.S. President Franklin D. Roosevelt.[4] As a first lady during World War II, she also sold war bonds and raised money for servicemen's clubs. In May 1944, she and her husband hosted a dinner party in Charleston, West Virginia for the British Ambassador and his wife, who were visiting the United States to raise funds for the British War Relief Society.[5]
After her husband left office, the couple moved to Washington, D.C., where Matthew Neely served in the United States Senate until his death in 1958.[6] In 1963, her portrait was one of eleven new portraits that were hung in the governor's mansion in Charleston, West Virginia. It was officially presented to the state during an unveiling ceremony on July 10 of that year.[7]
Following the death of her husband, Neely lived in Fairmont, West Virginia, where she died on June 30, 1976.[8]