All This to Say I Love You Tour

All shows featured the same setlist, blending released songs with unreleased songs and covers:

1. Daydreaming - from debut EP
2. Hello There - unreleased
3. Boy in Love - from debut EP
4. Mr E - unreleased
5. I Can’t Stay Away - from debut EP
6. He Doesn’t Make Me Cry - unreleased
7. Sweetness - from debut EP
8. American Dream - unreleased
9. Guitar Man - cover
10. Unchained Melody - cover
11. Who Knew Dancing Was a Sin - from debut EP
12. I Think They Call This Love - from debut EP

Reay was accompanied on stage by Harry Howell on guitar, and Caleb Wilson on an upright acoustic bass.^[3] No backing tracks were used.^[4]

The stage was modeled as a living room,^[2] with an armchair, a lamp, vinyl records (Elvis Presley, The Everly Brothers, among others), a rotary dial telephone, and artificial roses which Reay gave to audience members during and after the shows.^[4]

All concerts were sold out.^[4] Reviews are unanimously positive.^[2][3][5] According to reviews, Reay energized and engaged tour concert audiences that were made up of "all ages and backgrounds",^[3] with a sound that is "new to younger generations and nostalgic to older audiences", appealing to all.^[2]

A review of the show in Manchester by Adrenaline describes Reay's rendition of Unchained Melody as superbly controlled and loved by the crowd.^[3] A review of the same show by Northern Exposure refers to Reay's vocal prowess and his ability to connect with the musical heritage of the 1950s and 1960s, "drawing in fans with every note and lyric, creating an atmosphere that feels both nostalgic and refreshingly modern".^[5]

The venue in London is described by Rodeo as "cozy, quaint and warm," with fans transported to a bygone era by Reay’s vintage style and showmanship: “from the initial first note … the screams were deafening,” likened to a “prom scene in Grease”.^[2]

Reay's performance on stage is further described as "high on musicality with a respectful 50s vibe", captivating, and charismatic, with his voice called phenomenal, "like caramel", and likened to that of an angel.^[2][3][5]