And the Land Lay Still

The award-winning epic novel received near-unanimous critical acclaim in the mainstream British press.

For The Independent, the “dizzying grand opus” was “eminently readable” and successful in showcasing “an alternative history of the country told by its everyday people instead of its movers and shakers”.^[2]

The Observer said that Robertson had “caught something of the sheer bloody-minded craving for self-sabotage in the Scottish soul so accurately it's painful”.^[3] The Herald was impressed by “a state-of-the-nation novel with a Dickensian scope”.^[4]

The Daily Telegraph was impressed by the book’s ability to meld “engrossing individual storylines” with “cultural shifts such as the birth of Scottish nationalism, the death of industry, the sexual revolution and the boom in North Sea oil”.^[5] The New Statesman noted that four years’ worth of research had gone into the book and finished its review with the line: “It’s some achievement”.^[6]

Writing in The Guardian, the writer Irvine Welsh said of the "highly ambitious" book that it “represents nothing less than a landmark for the novel in Scotland, and underlines the author's position as one of Britain's best contemporary novelists”.^[7] Scotland First Minister Alex Salmond selected the novel as his book of the year for 2010, telling the Scotland on Sunday that it was “outstanding”, “important”, and the author’s finest work.^[8]

The novel won the 2010 Scottish Book of the Year Award^[9] and was long-listed for the 2011 Creative Scotland Book of the Year Awards.^[10]

• The List: James Robertson on And the Land Lay Still
• And the Land Lay Still book review roundup at Omnivore