Andy Graver

Graver was born in 1927 in Craghead, County Durham.^[4][5] His father, Fred, played professional football in the 1920s.^[6] He worked as a coal miner while playing for Willington and then for Annfield Plain. He signed for Newcastle United as a professional footballer before the 1947–48 season, and played regularly for the reserve team in the Central League, but his only game for Newcastle's first team came on 21 January 1950, standing in for the injured Jackie Milburn in a First Division match at home to Manchester City which finished 1–1.^[5][7] In September 1950, Lincoln City manager Bill Anderson persuaded the player to sign for the Third Division club for a fee of £5,000.^[4]

In his first season at Lincoln Graver scored 20 goals in League and FA Cup, losing out as leading scorer by one goal to Johnny Garvie.^[8] The following year, Garvie again scored 21 goals, but Graver's 39 (36 in the League from only 35 games) not only made him the club's top scorer but made a major contribution to Lincoln winning the Third Division North title and promotion to the Second Division.^[5] Graver scored 36 goals from only 35 games in 1951–52, including a double hat-trick (six goals) – two scored with his right foot, two with his left, and two headers – as Lincoln beat Crewe Alexandra 11–1.^[4] He injured a cartilage later that season so was unable to accept an invitation to appear for the England B team.^[4] Graver was Lincoln's top scorer for the next two seasons, with 18 and 25 goals respectively.^[5]

Described in his club profile as "fast, direct, and above all a fine opportunist in front of goal", Graver soon attracted attention from other clubs. Early on in his Lincoln career the club rejected an offer of £12,500 from Norwich City for his services.^[4] Nottingham Forest made several bids for the player.^[9] In December 1954, he signed for First Division strugglers Leicester City for a fee of £27,500 plus the player Eric Littler, valued at £600,^[4] a Leicester City club record,^[10] and little below the £30,000 paid by Tottenham Hotspur for Northern Ireland international and Aston Villa captain Danny Blanchflower not long before. Graver, described as "reluctantly" leaving Lincoln, said he was "afraid of the responsibility of living up to such a price tag".^[9]

Playing alongside Leicester's record goalscorer Arthur Rowley, Graver scored in his first two games, but produced little more as the club failed to avoid relegation.^[7][11] Lincoln paid £14,000 for Graver's return, but a few months later he moved on again, this time to Second Division Stoke City for a "large" fee.^[4] He had less success at Stoke, producing 12 goals from 37 League games over a season and a half.^[12] In August 1957, expectation was that he would return again to Lincoln; terms were agreed between the clubs, but Boston United – where his brother Alf was already playing – made the player a better contract offer.^[13][14] Not only did Boston pay a Midland League record fee of £3,500 for Graver, they also signed Johnny Garvie from Carlisle United with the intention of reviving their previous goalscoring partnership.^[14]

Graver provided 24 League goals in the 1957–58 season^[14] as Boston finished in third place in the Midland League.^[15] He remained with the club as they began their 1958 campaign in the Southern League, scoring at a goal a game, before returning to Lincoln City for his third spell.^[14] He stayed with Lincoln until the end of the 1960–61 season, bringing his goals total to 150 from 289 games in all competitions and establishing his position as Lincoln's all-time top scorer.^[3] After retiring from full-time football, he played for Skegness Town and then for Ilkeston Town, where he was reunited with Garvie yet again. However, injury restricted Garvie to five appearances, and although Graver's 16 goals made him leading scorer in 1962–63, and contributed to a fourth-place finish in the Midland Counties League and a Derbyshire Senior Cup-winner's medal, he was soon dropped to the reserves, where a broken ankle brought about his retirement as a player. He had scored 19 goals from 48 appearances in all first-team competitions for Ilkeston.^[16]

During the 1960s, Graver coached Lincoln City's youth team. He worked for a finance company in the Lincoln area for 30 years, and lived locally after retiring.^[4] Graver and 1950s teammate Tony Emery were the first two former players admitted to the club's Hall of Fame in May 1996.^[17] In 2006, Graver topped the poll as Lincoln fans voted for "100 League Legends" as part of the celebrations of the club's 100th season in the Football League.^[4][18] The following year, to mark the centenary of the Professional Footballers' Association (PFA), supporters were asked to vote for their club's all-time favourite player; Graver was again the Lincoln City choice.^[19]

He moved to York in later life to be nearer family, and died there in 2014, aged 86.^[20][1]

Lincoln City

• Football League Third Division North champion: 1951–52