Awarding the album three and a half stars at CCM Magazine, Jamie Walker describes, "Musically, the album weaves a subtle path between worship genre favorites, the more memorable moments following the throwback trend of 80s-influenced synth pop."[1] Darryl Bryant, giving the album four stars from Worship Leader, writes, "Eleven22 are at their best and balanced with duets but Before All Things delivers worship beyond the Church."[4] Rating the album three and a half stars for New Release Today, Marcus Hathcock states, "The Church of Eleven22 certainly deserves some more attention and credibility as a worship movement from Before All Things. The production value, vocal prowess and, most of all, lyrical depth set it apart in a crowded and growing crop of church-based worship albums."[3] Andrew Wallace, indicating in a nine out of ten review by Cross Rhythms, says, "A varied, mature, multi-textured album with many layers and nuances to be uncovered; on-par with better-known brands such as Jesus Culture and Hillsong United."[2]
