Black Sheep Boy

Most of the songs for the record were written in February 2004 in Bloomington, Indiana by Will Sheff. Sheff describes the album's theme in a 2005 interview:

"The Black Sheep Boy is a fantastical character that crops up here and there on the album. In the lyrics pretty much anything in quotes is the voice of the Black Sheep Boy. I think a lot of the dirtier, rougher, more obtuse songs are the product of the Black Sheep Boy."^[2]

The writing of the album took place during a difficult time for the band. The relative lack of commercial success of their previous albums meant that the band's future was in doubt and Sheff was rendered homeless in order to make ends meet and afford the costs related to the band's commitments.^[3]

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
Metacritic	86/100[4]
Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[5]
Alternative Press	5/5[6]
The Boston Phoenix	[7]
The Guardian	[8]
Mojo	[9]
Pitchfork	8.5/10[10]
PopMatters	9/10[11]
Q	[12]
Slant Magazine	[13]
Uncut	[14]

Black Sheep Boy has received general acclaim. On the review aggregate site Metacritic, the album has a score of 86 out of 100, indicating "universal acclaim".^[4]

The album was ranked number 22 on Amazon.com's Top 50 Albums of 2005 list.^[15] The music online magazine Pitchfork placed Black Sheep Boy at number 174 on their list of top 200 albums of the 2000s.^[16]

In 2015, Okkervil River released an expanded three-disc re-issue of Black Sheep Boy to commemorate the album's 10th anniversary, including the Black Sheep Boy Appendix EP in its entirety and a disc consisting of previously unreleased covers.^[17]