Awarding the album four stars from New Release Today, Kevin Davis states, "This is a very emotional album and if you're not familiar with Brady’s passionate vocal style, this album is hook-filled with catchy melodies wrapped around very introspective, worshipful and emotional lyrics."[3] James Yelland, rating the album a nine out of ten for Cross Rhythms, writes, "With a vintage yet contemporary sound, this album feels awash with the sound of his Nashville base ... A fine album."[1] Giving the album four stars at Indie Vision Music, Sara Walz describes, "Brady Toops is a collection of songs that will calm the heart and pierce the soul."[2]
