Awarding the EP three stars for CCM Magazine, Grace S. Aspinwall writes, this is "a promising start for the newcomers."[1] Sarah Fine, rating the EP three and a half stars at New Release Tuesday, states, the music comes "With lyrical depth and the musical chops to back it up".[9] Giving the EP four stars from Jesus Freak Hideout, Matthew Morris says, "Breathe in Deep is a strong effort".[7]
Jonathan Andre, awarding the EP three stars by Indie Vision Music, describes, "Well done guys for such a unique and out of the box album!"[6] Eliot Rose, giving the EP an eight out of ten, writes, "the disc packs a punch from the opening track".[5] Amanda Brogan, rating the EP a three and a half out of five for Christian Music Review, states, "Carrollton has created a sound that perfectly fits with their namesake."[2]
Giving the EP a 4.25 out of five from Christian Music Zine, Joshua Andre writes, "Carrollton’s Centricity Records’ debut is something to savour".[3] Jono Davies, rating the EP four stars at Louder Than the Music, says, he "really appreciate[d] the quality of the musicianship on this record."[8] Awarding the EP four stars for CM Addict, Brianne Bellomy states, "The songs are written from their daily lives, honest and upfront."[4]
