Brilliant Mistake

"Brilliant Mistake" was first attempted by Costello in his sessions with his longstanding backing band the Attractions.^[7] Costello had already recorded half of the King of America album without them, rendering the recording sessions tense. Costello had expected for the Attractions to perform on the song, but he expressed disappointment with their performance, saying, "I had little patience for our failure to get to grips with the one song I had been certain would suit the band's sound and was fast becoming the session's theme song: 'Brilliant Mistake'. ... Despite any other departures, I wanted to lead off with an Attractions recording. This was not to be".^[2]

The final version would be recorded with the Confederates, Costello's backing band throughout the album that included members of the TCB Band. Drummer Mickey Curry played with brushes on the track, while Jerry Scheff played string bass and future Costello producer Mitchell Froom played organ and harpsichord.^[2] T-Bone Wolk, played Fender Telecaster and accordion.

"Brilliant Mistake" was released as the opening track to the King of America album in February 1986. Costello explained, "Apart from the lyric providing the album's title, I had always seen this song as the record's opening track".^[2] The track was not initially released as a single, but it saw a single release in 2005 with a cover of Buddy Holly's "True Love Ways" on the B-side. The track also appeared on Girls Girls Girls, of which he joked, "At best ['Brilliant Mistake'] might be called the title track of the collection".^[8]

"Brilliant Mistake" has since seen critical acclaim. Pitchfork Media praised the song as one of the songs on the album "imbued" with "barbed wit and acid humor", while AllMusic noted that Costello "rarely got better" than on the track.^[9][10] Salon dubbed it "a hugely ambitious song that eviscerates, in vertiginous order, the American way of life, romance and then the singer's personality itself".^[11] Ed Masley of The Arizona Republic called it "prime Costello, a reflective gem".^[12]

Jim Beviglia of American Songwriter named it Costello's 13th best song, saying "'Brilliant Mistake' may indeed be an affectionate send-up of the land of the free, but it's also a moving portrait of a man lost in translation".^[13] Dave Lifton of Ultimate Classic Rock ranked it as Costello's 8th best, while Martin Chilton of the Daily Telegraph named it his 17th best.^[14][15]

The song was also the title track for the Broadway tribute Brilliant Mistake: Broadway Sings Elvis Costello.^[16]

A new 2024 recording of "Brilliant Mistake" was released on the super deluxe box set King of America & Other Realms on 1 November 2024, along with a demo and a new remaster of the original recording. Costello said of the 2024 remake's new arrangement is "over a habanera rhythm in a minor key to mark the dark passing of the years and our elusive hold on hope, taking a detour into the 1933 Harry Warren/Al Dubin song 'Boulevard of Broken Dreams', rather than just alluding to it in the lyric of the last verse."^[17][18]

Citations

Sources

• Costello, Elvis (2016). Unfaithful Music & Disappearing Ink. New York: Blue Rider Press. ISBN 978-0399185762.
• Perone, James E. (2015). The Words and Music of Elvis Costello. Praeger. ISBN 978-1440832154.
• Thomson, Graeme (2006). Complicated Shadows: The Life and Music of Elvis Costello. Canongate U.S. ISBN 978-1841957968.