Christ Church was founded as an Episcopal congregation in the then-fast-growing frontier city of Chicago around 1855.[1] According to news sources in the 1890s, its building at South Michigan Avenue and 24th Street was built about 1860.[2] Also in 1860, a newly ordained Episcopal priest named Charles E. Cheney was called as rector.[3]
Cheney was part of the low-church evangelical party in the Episcopal Church and objected to the then-ascendant Anglo-Catholic movement. In a disagreement over baptismal regeneration, Cheney omitted the word "regenerate" as part of the baptismal liturgy and was subjected to an ecclesiastical trial in 1869. Bishop Henry J. Whitehouse deposed him in 1871, and in 1873, Cheney participated in the founding of the Reformed Episcopal Church, which separated from the Episcopal Church. He was elected to serve as a missionary bishop for the northwest area—soon to become the REC Synod of Chicago—and he served in this capacity until his death. George D. Cummins consecrated Cheney a bishop on December 14, 1873, and Christ Church joined the REC early in 1874.[4]
Notable members of Christ Church during Cheney's rectorate included Charles Fargo, younger brother of William Fargo and J. C. Fargo,[5] and George Bangs. Funeral services for Bangs were held at Christ Church in 1877.[6]
Cheney died in 1916 after 56 years in continuous service as rector of Christ Church.[7] In 1920, due to the widening of roads surrounding the building―what the Reformed Episcopal Church called the "imperious demands of the automobile industry which have been made upon Michigan Avenue, once marked by the most beautiful and costly homes of Chicago"―the congregation was forced by "stern necessity" to sell the building. Members of Christ Church joined other REC churches across Chicago.[8]
