City of Beautiful Nonsense (1935 film)

The Monthly Film Bulletin wrote: "The story, a straightforward one about ordinary likeable people, develops naturally with plenty of incident, and holds the interest. Pathos and humour are judiciously mingled, neither being overdone. The casting is excellent; the minor as well as the more important parts give ample opportunity for good acting, and full advantage is taken of this. Much of the dialogue is taken direct from the novel. There are some very good shots of Venetian scenery, and the sound of the swirling and sucking of the water as a gondola passes by is particularly effective. Music, introduced where suitable opportunity offers itself, adds considerably to the attraction of an altogether pleasing film."^[3]

The Daily Film Renter wrote: "Story seems trifle old-fashioned, but scores on angles of fragrant sentiment that were features of original. Picturesque Venetian exteriors alternate with squalid lodgings, Hyde Park, church and apartment locales. Emlyn Williams gives smooth performance in lead, George Carney registering prominently as cockney bailiff. Acceptable entertainment for the masses, with title exploitation angles."^[4]

Kine Weekly wrote: "Simple romantic drama, a happy, appealing piece of make-believe, straightforwardly adapted from E. Temple Thurston's popular novel, and set in a harmonious atmosphere. The treatment is at times heavy-handed; but imagination is to be found in the generous spirit of the theme. It looks on life kindly, and finds its sympathetic, charming entertainment in the accuracy with which it is interpreted by the principal players. Very good booking fo the masses and family halls, with indisputable title values."^[5]

Picturegoer wrote: "In a simple manner the way of true love is smoothed out with a nicely balanced sentimentality and a certain artless charm. The acting too is natural. Emlyn Williams makes the most of the role of Jack Grey and graces it with conviction while Sophie Stewart – of whom we should see a good deal more – is most appealing as Jill. Eric Maturin is good as the fiancé while light relief is admirably supplied by George Carney as a kind-hearted bailiff."^[6]

• City of Beautiful Nonsense at IMDb
• City of Beautiful Nonsense at BFI Film & TV Database