Tom Zunder reviewed Combat Showcase for Adventurer magazine and stated that "In summary, Muskogee is very much what you make of it. It's a large duelling track and since it would cost you at least £2.50 to buy the gridded paper from a graphics shop (plus the time in drawing it out), is certainly value in financial terms. However, whether you want a huge duelling area must be your choice, since that is alt you get (The 14 scenarios which the cover boasts are actually directions in which to drive and one payroll heist). To give my playtesters as an example, two of us would have bought it, one would have knocked up his own and the other couldn't decide."[1]