| Year |
School |
Venue |
MVP |
| 2000 |
Southern Miss |
Oak Grove Optimist Park • Hattiesburg, MS |
Courtney Blades, Southern Miss |
| 2001 |
Southern Miss |
Ulmer Stadium • Louisville, KY |
Felicia Gonzales, Southern Miss |
| 2002 |
DePaul |
USF Softball Complex • Tampa, FL |
Lindsay Chouinard, DePaul |
| 2003 |
DePaul |
Cougar Softball Stadium • Houston, TX |
Lindsay Chouinard, DePaul |
| 2004 |
DePaul |
Ulmer Stadium • Louisville, KY |
Sarah Martz, DePaul |
| 2005 |
DePaul |
USF Softball Complex • Tampa, FL |
Megan Huitink, DePaul |
| 2006 |
Tulsa |
Donna J. Hardesty Sports Complex • Tulsa, OK |
Julia Fennell, Tulsa |
| 2007 |
Houston |
UCF Softball Complex • Orlando, FL |
Angel Shamblin, Houston |
| 2008 |
UCF |
Cougar Softball Stadium • Houston, TX |
Tiffany Lane, UCF |
| 2009 |
Tulsa |
Helen of Troy Softball Complex • El Paso, TX |
Lauren Lindsay, Tulsa |
| 2010 |
East Carolina |
Cougar Softball Stadium • Houston, TX |
Toni Paisley, East Carolina |
| 2011 |
East Carolina |
ECU Softball Stadium • Greenville, NC |
Priscilla Velasquez, East Carolina |
| 2012 |
Tulsa |
UAB Softball Field • Birmingham, AL |
Lacey Middlebrooks, Tulsa |
| 2013 |
Marshall |
Collins Family Softball Complex • Tusla, OK |
Andi Williamson, Marshall |
| 2014 |
Tulsa |
FAU Softball Stadium • Boca Raton, FL |
Aimee Creger, Tulsa |
| 2015 |
Western Kentucky |
Felsburg Field at FIU Stadium • Miami, FL |
Miranda Kramer, Western Kentucky |
| 2016 |
Florida Atlantic |
Loveland Field • Denton, TX |
Kylee Hanson, Florida Atlantic |
| 2017 |
Louisiana Tech |
Southern Miss Softball Complex • Hattiesburg, MS |
Pauline Tufi, Louisiana Tech |
| 2018 |
Middle Tennessee |
Sue M. Daughtridge Stadium • Charlotte, NC |
Cori Jennings, Middle Tennessee |
| 2019 |
Louisiana Tech |
Mary Bowers Field • Birmingham, AL |
Jazlyn Crowder, Louisiana Tech |
| 2020 |
Cancelled due to the coronavirus pandemic |
| 2021 |
Western Kentucky |
WKU Softball Complex • Bowling Green, KY |
Kennedy Sullivan, Western Kentucky |
| 2022 |
North Texas |
Lovelace Stadium • Denton, TX |
Molly Rainey, North Texas |
| 2023 |
Middle Tennessee |
Dr. Billy Bundrick Field • Ruston, LA |
Shelby Sargent, Middle Tennessee |
| 2024 |
Liberty |
NM State Softball Complex • Las Cruces, NM |
Brooke Roberts, Liberty |
| 2025 |
Liberty |
WKU Softball Complex • Bowling Green, KY |
Elena Escobar, Liberty |