Crossgates Quarry appears on maps as early as 1854, along with 11 lime kilns in the vicinity.[4] In 1857, Anglo-Saxon human remains were found at the quarry and investigated by Lord Londesborough.[5]
The quarry was home to a lime works. In 1932, there was a fire at an engine shed there, which was attended by Scarborough fire brigade and Viscount Downe's private fire brigade from Wykeham Abbey. Scarborough fire brigade did not attempt to put out the fire as they had no agreement to operate outside the borough.[6] Residents near the quarry complained of noise in 1961 when a new plant was being installed.[7]
In 1983, the quarry was mooted as a potential development site for housing, agriculture, or commerce.[8]