Awarding the album three stars from CCM Magazine, Matt Conner states, "DNA features several straightforward originals that speak to typical themes, but congregations should find several songs to appreciate".[1] Tony Cummings, rating the album a nine out of ten at Cross Rhythms, writes, "This is one of their best."[3] Giving the album four stars for New Release Today, Christopher Thiessen describes, "DNA is a great worship experience that will lead listeners to worship God throughout the entirety of the album."[6] Dave Wood, awarding the album four stars from Louder Than the Music, says, "'DNA' is an inspired, innovative album, polished and sparkling, bursting full of energy, and with a heartfelt passion that is both infectious and appealing."[5] Rating the album an eight out of ten for Jesus Wired, Rebekah Joy states, "DNA is a great album that will be loved by many".[4] Leah St. John, giving the album four and a half stars at Christian Review Magazine, writes, "[It] is a great release that brings 80's synth and alternative rock together in a way that will help redefine and alter the DNA of worship, making it more accessible to a modern audience."[2]
