In 2018, DeleteMe was reviewed by Steven Petrow of USA Today.[2] In 2021, DeleteMe was reviewed by Neil J. Rubenking of PCMag.[8]
In 2024, a Consumer Reports study found that DeleteMe removed 27% of results from 13 tested people-search sites within 4 months of sign-up, compared to 70% for manual removals. Among similar services tested, DeleteMe was described as a "midlevel" performer. Consumer reports commented on DeleteMe's privacy policy, which allows for the sale or transfer of user data in the event of a business transaction, saying "Some privacy-minded subscribers might not want their information to be used this way."[10]
In 2025, the New York Times Wirecutter review section called DeleteMe the "best data removal service," citing its ease of use and setup. "It’s comprehensive—covering names, addresses, and even relatives—but flexible enough that you don’t need to remember every little detail to reap the benefits," the review concluded.[11]