Dellmus Colvin

In November 2005, based on the results from the DNA analysis, Colvin was charged with the murders of two women: 33-year-old Jackie Simpson and 37-year-old Melissa Weber, who were murdered in Toledo on April 16 and May 9, 2003, respectively. In addition, he was charged with a rape that occurred that same year.^[10] In September 2006, Colvin stood trial for the murders. During said trial, the Lucas County Attorney General's Office, which suspected Colvin was responsible for more murders due to his occupation as a truck driver, proposed a plea bargain in exchange for taking the death penalty off the table. Agreeing to the proposal, Dellmus pleaded guilty to the murders of Simpson and Weber, as well as three others. According to his testimony, in January 2000, he lured 38-year-old Valerie Jones into his truck, strangled her, and then dumped her body in Lake Erie, in Ottawa County; on September 1 of that year, he lured 42-year-old Jacquelynn Thomas into his truck's cabin, after which he violated^{[clarification needed][failed verification]} and subsequently killed her. Her body was found the next day in Monroe County. He also killed 43-year-old Lily Summers, whom he had previously offered money in exchange for sex; her body was found in April 2002.^[11][12]

On October 3, 2006, Colvin unexpectedly confessed to another murder. He admitted to his involvement in the murder of 40-year-old Dorothea Wetzel, who was found murdered on August 5, 2000, on the banks of the Maumee River in southern Toledo. During interrogation, Colvin stated that his motive for the killings was misogyny, which was caused by his sexual complexes and inferiority complex.^[13] In October of that year, on the basis of the plea bargain, he was given several terms of life imprisonment.^[14]

In June 2010, Colvin was charged with the cold case murder of 27-year-old Donna Lee White, who was killed on September 15, 1987, in Atlantic City. Dellmus was extradited to New Jersey, where he appeared before the court in April 2011.^[15] During the trial, he pled guilty to White's murder. In his statement, he claimed to have met Donna while working as a taxi driver, after which he made the girl an offer to go to his apartment, where they would drink and have sex, to which she supposedly agreed. A few hours later, Donna began taking drugs, and fainted from an overdose. However, instead of helping her, Colvin strangled her with a plastic bag and then dumped the body on the outskirts of the city.^[16]

Based on his testimony, in April 2011, Dellmus Colvin was convicted of White's murder and received an additional 30 years imprisonment, to be served concurrently with his life sentences.^[17]

In September 2020, during a telephone conversation with podcaster Phil Chalmers, Colvin claimed that, between 1983 and 2005, he killed 52 girls and women across the United States. To support his claims, he shared details about the murder of a prostitute he committed in 2005 in LaSalle County, Illinois, near Ottawa. According to his testimony, after committing the murder, he dumped the victim's body in an abandoned building located in the small town of Peru. Following Colvin's statement, the LaSalle County Sheriff authorized a search at the designated dump site, resulting in two bones, believed to belong to a woman's skeleton, were found by law enforcement officials. They were subsequently taken to a forensic anthropologist for identification, but found to be non-human.^[18][19][20]

• List of serial killers in the United States