Diorygma incantatum grows as an opaque, irregular, whitish grey crust on the bark substrate. It lacks soredia and isidia (vegetative propagules). Its ascomata are white, have a rounded to irregular shape, and measure 0.6–1.6 by 0.3–0.6 mm; they have a pinkish disc with white pruina. The major distinguishing characteristic of the lichen are its threadlike (filiform) ascospores, which measure 105–108 by 6 μm and have from 29 to 31 transverse septa.[1]
At the time of publication, only four other Diorygma species were known to have transverse septa in their ascospores. These lichens (D. circumfusum, D. minisporum, D. wallamanense, and D. wilsonianum ) can be distinguished from D. incantatum by differences in distribution and in spore dimensions and structure. Additionally, D. incantatum contains an unknown lichen product that forms a purple spot when analysed and separated with thin-layer chromatography; this spot will fluoresce orange when lit with an ultraviolet light. The authors also noted a resemblance with Chapsa indica, a species which differs from D. incantatum in that it contains periphysoids, and it lacks lichen products.[1]