In the fall of her junior year at Bryn Mawr, DeGarmo committed to play for the Princeton University women's lacrosse team.
DeGarmo made the Ivy League All-Tournament Team and was named Ivy League Defensive Player of the Week.[2] She started all 20 games and made 134 saves (46.8% save percentage).[3]
DeGarmo was unanimously named Ivy League Defender of the Year, earning first-team, all-Ivy honors.[4] A Tewaaraton Trophy top-25 finalist, she led the nation with a 55.7% regular season save percentage.[5]
DeGarmo was named Ivy League Defensive Player of the Week three times.[6] She received them after stopping career-highs of 13, 14, and 16 shots against UVA, Harvard, and Cornell, respectively.[7][8] She started all 15 games, and has made 157 saves (55.7% save percentage).[9]
For the second year in a row, DeGarmo was unanimously named Ivy League Defender of the Year, earning first-team, all-Ivy honors.[10] A Tewaaraton Trophy top-25 finalist, she led the nation with a 55.4% regular season save percentage with an average of 12.57 saves per game.[10] With 235 saves over the season, DeGarmo set the single-season save record for Princeton.