The pseudo-atoll's chronology is developed from deposition of a variety of community organisms. The oldest are the early Piacenzian communities of shallow intertidal muddy-sand Mercenaria tridacnoides community of clam species, the deep lagoon Nodipecten peedeensis community of scallops, the shallow lagoon Apicula buckinghamensis community of tower shell snails, and lagoon coral Phyllangia blakei community.
The second time period is mid-Piacenzian and contains the shallow muddy intertidal Strombus floridanus (conch) communities, shallow lagoon tower shell snail Apicula gladeensis community, lagoon scallop Nodipecten floridensis community, and the shallow lagoon Hyotissa meridionalis community of foam oysters.
The third time period is the late Piacenzian and contained wave-action related coral zones of open ocean to sheltered basin. The communities are the high energy open ocean Pocillopora crassoramosa community of the coral reef crest. The back reef Dichocoenia tuberosa community of coral, the low energy back reef Isophyllia desotonsis community of coral, the sheltered back reef Stylophora affinis community, and sheltered reef lagoon Antillia bilobata community of coral.
The fourth was during the maximum development of the Myakka Lagoon System estuary and included the mudflat mangrove forests of the Pyrazisinus scalinus community, and the shallow and muddy lagoon clam beds of the Mulinia sapotilla community. Later the shallow lagoon mussel shoals of the Perna conradiana community and shallow lagoon Chama emmonsii community. The Kissimmee Embayment contained the shallow mangrove forests and mudflat Pyrazisinus kissimmeesis community of sea snails and sand flats and turtle grass of the Siphocypraea kissimmeesis community.