Every Night the Same Dream

The album was noted for its "unpredictable", "explorative" sound taking influence from a range of genres including psychedelic rock, acoustic rock and grunge.^[4] This stands in contrast to their previous record from 2014, Puddinghead, "an album full of outrageous pop hooks and sleek production".^[5]

The band's longest song and lead single "Pariah" is described as a "moody, seven-minute aural journey" recorded from a live jam session.^[6] Online publication AAA Backstage found "Leef" to have similar elements to tracks from Ball Park Music's debut album Happiness and Surrounding Suburbs (2011), with the author calling it one of "the band’s most beautiful song[s]".^[5] The closing track "Suit Yourself", is described as a softer jam with a "pulsating, glitchy, emotion-filled" vocal delivery.^[4]

Margy Noble of The AU Review noted a change in sonic direction half-way through the album, writing it "ought to be listened to on vinyl" as "there’s a real feel that the record has been flipped, and you’re about to discover the treasures of the B side".^[6]

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
AAA Backstage	[5]
The AU Review	8.2/10[6]
Forte	[7]

Some critics, including Noble, called Every Night the Same Dream the band's best album yet.^[5][6] She elaborated in an 8.2 out of 10 review: "It's an unpredictable, heartfelt LP, where you'll fall between progressive psych-rock jams, indie rock and pop ballads".^[6] Writing for Music Feeds, Zanda Wilson said the album is "easily Ball Park Music's biggest achievement to date".^[4] Beat Magazine called the album "a stand out record for 2016".^[8]