Faithful (1996 film)

The film was received poorly at the box office, grossing just $2,104,439. It was a huge drop compared to Cher's previous starring role, Mermaids, which grossed $35,419,397 in 1990.^[5] The film's opening weekend of just $967,956 would end as 46% of the film's total gross.^[3] This film was Cher's least successful film of the decade in a starring role.

The film was also widely panned by film critics, earning a 6% "rotten" rating on the website Rotten Tomatoes from 16 reviews.^[6] Multiple critics remarked that the story had obviously been written for theatre, and had not converted well to the motion picture medium.^[7][8] Writing in Entertainment Weekly, Owen Gleiberman described it as "an awkward hybrid of Deathtrap, Scenes from a Marriage, and a David Mamet barstool rant."^[9] The Austin Chronicle gave it one and a half stars, commenting that "The dialogue packs a lot of witty one-liners, yet their power is insufficient to carry this dud. ... The comedy never works up enough froth to overcome the movie's implausibility. Palminteri is carving himself a familiar niche as a personifier of tough guys with soft spots, but this chatty hit man is not of this world."^[7] Roger Ebert similarly praised the dialogue as clever but felt it was outweighed by the predictable plot and logic holes such as the "kill" signal being two telephone rings (apparently leaving no room for the possibilities of someone else calling the house or of Jack calling the hit off). He gave Faithful two and a half stars, summarizing it as "the kind of movie that's diverting while you're watching it, mostly because of the actors' appeal, but it evaporates the moment it's over, because it’s not really about anything. Nothing is at stake, the relationships are not three-dimensional enough for us to care about them, and it's likely that nobody will get killed."^[8]

• Faithful at IMDb