Haines Shoe House

Haines never lived in the shoe house but in his later years after marrying his second wife he built a home across the street.^[8] The shoe house was initially made available as a weekend vacation spot for 38 elderly couples a year;^[6] the first such couple were John F. and Liza Baum of Loganville.^[9][10] Shoe House vacation contests were also held for a few seasons among newlyweds affiliated with Haines' shoe stores; an early winner in 1950 had all expenses paid for a week, including the service of a maid and chauffeur, and went home with a free pair of shoes.^[6] The house was offered for rent by the public in the mid-1950s.^[11]

Upon Haines' death in 1962, the house was given to his employees, who sold it two years later to a dentist; after about 20 years of tours and service as an ice cream parlor,^[12] it started going to ruin until it was bought in 1987 by Haines' granddaughter, Annie Haines Keller, who began renovations.^[7] After Keller could no longer maintain the house, it was sold to Charles and Ruth Miller, who gave tours for eight years before selling it in 2003 to Colleen and Ronald Farabaugh.^[12] The house received a small renovation and new paint in 2007.^[6] The seventh owners were Jeff and Melanie Schmuck, who bought the house in 2015.^[9][13][14] In 2018, with help by a local lift truck company, a water leak in the house's "toe" was repaired and the exterior was painted in the original canary-yellow color, with a brown sole and highlights added.^[15] Co-owner Melanie Schmuck died from "health complications" in February 2019.^[16] In late June 2022, Jeff Schmuck announced that a local family was buying the house at the end of July, with plans to offer it for rental via Airbnb; public tours were to have ended on July 24, 2022.^[2] Completion of the sale to Waylon and Naomi Brown was announced in August. Four beds provide sleeping space for up to six people in three renovated bedrooms named "Shoelace Space", "Instep Suite", and "Ankle Abode". All rooms are reportedly filled with shoe memorabilia, and "shoevenirs" are available for sale on the lowest level.^[17] The property began rentals via Airbnb in late 2022.^[18]

The Shoe House was visited in the eighth season of the reality television series The Amazing Race,^[19] originally broadcast in 2005, and was featured on HGTV's What's With That House in 2007. The Farabaughs were happy about the publicity though not permitted to talk about the house's appearance on The Amazing Race until two years later.^[20]

The Shoe House received a historical marker from the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission in July 2023.^[21] In July 2025, the house was given top honors among three featured in the second-season premiere of HGTV's Zillow Gone Wild.^[22]

• Official website
• Historic American Engineering Record (HAER) No. PA-610, "Haines Shoe House, Hallam, York County, PA", 6 photos, 1 photo caption page

39°59′56″N 76°38′13″W / 39.99889°N 76.63694°W / 39.99889; -76.63694