Reception to Wheels of Freedom was mixed. Reviewers noted improvements over the previous game, but complained about the game's AI and technical issues. The multiplayer component was also put into question, mainly due to sparse player counts in spite of its use of a matchmaking service and limited options.
Stephen Poole of GameSpot said, "If you're looking for high-performance motorcycle racing on the PC, you'll tap this one out in very short order.". They awarded the game a score of 5.3 (mediocre).[3] In a similarly mixed review, Vincent Lopez of IGN noted the graphical improvements over the previous game, its open-ended structure and the inclusion of GameSpy Arcade, but criticized its erratic AI and easy difficulty, saying "If, perhaps, you enjoy spending your money on things of value, such as say... well, any other game on the market, than you should probably take the twenty bucks and get yourself Superbike 2001, or at least something a little more valuable."[5]
A more positive review came from Shawn Snider of GamingExcellence, who deemed it "a very large step up from its predecessor", yet noted the game's easy difficulty and poor vehicle handling.[4]