If You Only Knew (Acetone album)

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[9]
Edmonton Journal	[10]
The Great Alternative & Indie Discography	5/10[11]
MusicHound Rock: The Essential Album Guide	[12]
Pitchfork	8.5/10[5]
The Virgin Encyclopedia of Nineties Music	[13]

The Edmonton Journal opined that "Acetone comes off like Chris Isaak on downers, or a more cohesive Velvet Underground ... Steve Hadley shuffles subtly on drums, rarely breaking that beat-per-second limit, while guitarist Mark Lightcap noodles along dreamily"; the paper later listed If You Only Knew as one of the best albums of 1996.^[10][14] The Gazette said that the band "takes the long and winding road through an atmospheric set of the Snooze Blues, the Coma Country."^[15] The Record concluded that "the druggy tempos and lethargic vocals, with the barest hint of Southern rock rhythms, make for an absolutely perfect Big Star Third clone on the title track".^[16]

The Province stated that "lilting, soft melodies are mixed with breathy lo-fi vocals to great success".^[17] The Rocket noted that "the slow motion, psych wander that Acetone have mastered shows off ropy trails of guitars, simple but effective drumming, and lost in the desert, deadpan vocals."^[18] CMJ New Music Monthly called the album "blurry-eyed rock [that] blends lethargic rhythms and lithe melodies".^[19] In 2023, Uncut said that "while some of [Richie] Lee's vocals sometimes feel a little lost and distant on the album, the band are capable of creating swirling atmospherics and hypnotic grooves".^[20]