The novel debuted at number twelve on The New York Times hardcover fiction bestsellers list on September 1, 2019.[4]
Ron Charles of The Washington Post praised the novel, writing, "The unsettling haze between fact and fantasy in Inland is not just a literary effect of Obreht's gorgeous prose; it's an uncanny representation of the indeterminate nature of life in this place of brutal geography."[5] Writing in The New York Times Book Review, Chanelle Benz stated, "Obreht's simple but rich prose captures and luxuriates in the West's beauty and sudden menace. Remarkable in a novel with such a sprawling cast, Obreht also has a poetic touch for writing intricate and precise character descriptions."[6]
Writing for the Los Angeles Times, Carolyn Kellogg gave the novel a mixed review, praising the characters of Lurie and Burke but lamented, "It's unfortunate that among all the varied characters we meet in Inland, Native Americans don't ever leave the periphery. It's a missed opportunity. At times, this sweeping story seems almost too big for even a writer of Obreht's gifts."[7]
Lily Meyer of NPR celebrated the novel, writing, "Inland is a classic story, told in a classic way — and yet it feels wholly and unmistakably new."[8] The reviewer concludes, "Obreht offers a new representation of the West, both in the characters she chooses and the emotional rigor and range with which she writes. The result is at once a new Western myth and a far realer story than many we have previously received — and that's even with all the ghosts."[8]