In 2005, incumbent Superintendent Trent Blankenship resigned as Superintendent, following conflict with Governor Freudenthal, to become superintendent of schools in Barrow, Alaska. Under state law, to fill the vacancy, the Republican Party of Wyoming would nominate three candidates, one of whom would be selected by the Governor. After a public selection process, the state party nominated McBride; Annette Bohling, an administrator within the state department; and Donald Bryngelson, the director of the state school facilities commission.[2] After interviewing the candidates, Freudenthal appointed McBride as Blankenship's replacement.[3]
McBride ran for re-election in 2006 and won the Republican primary unopposed. In the general election, he faced Michelle Hoffman, the Democratic nominee and the Superintendent of Fremont County School District No. 14. Hoffman attacked McBride for cuts that he had allegedly made to special education programs, though McBride's office contested the accuracy of her attacks.[4] The Casper Star-Tribune endorsed McBride for re-election, arguing that he "deserves to be elected to a full term to continue the work he has begun" and that he "brought stability to the department and put the employees on the same page."[5] Ultimately, McBride defeated Hoffman by a wide margin, winning 59% of the vote to her 41%.[6]
In 2010, McBride ran for a second full term, but faced significant opposition in the Republican primary. He was challenged by his predecessor, Trent Blankenship, along with assistant high school principal Cindy Hill and Ted Adams, the Laramie County School District No. 1 Superintendent. During the campaign, McBride was attacked over the administration of the state's standardized testing system.[7] He lost the Republican primary to Hill by a wide margin, winning just 25% of the vote to her 49%, while Blankenship won 15% and Adams won 11%.[8]