John F. J. Herbert

Herbert was born on May 14, 1874, in Worcester, Massachusetts.^[1] He was a standout athlete, rowing on the eight that won the 1893 New England Amateur Rowing Association regatta in 1893 and the 1895 National Association of Amateur Oarsmen's national championship. He competed in track at Worcester High School and played tackle for the school's football team. He was captain of the 1893 WHS football team, which was the first in school history to beat the Worcester Academy twice in one season.^[2]

Herbert joined the Massachusetts Volunteer Militia as a lieutenant on May 18, 1904. He served with Battery B of the 1st Battalion of Field Artillery. He was a captain when the battalion was mobilized to the Mexican border in June 1916.^[1] He was called to active duty on August 5, 1917, and promoted to major. He served overseas with the 102d Field Artillery. He was promoted to Lieutenant Colonel on June 29, 1918, and colonel on February 22, 1919.^[1] He was commander of the 102nd from August 13, 1918, to October 12, 1918. The regiment was demobilized on April 29, 1919. After the war, Herbert was an officer with the Massachusetts National Guard. He commanded the XI Corps Artillery Headquarters from November 1921 to January 1924 and the 180th Field Artillery Brigade from January 1924 to February 1924.^[3]

In May 1919, Herbert led the Massachusetts delegation the American Legion's St. Louis Caucus and was elected to the organization's national executive committee.^[4] He spoke against the proposal to hold the group's first national convention in Chicago due to mayor William Hale Thompson's neutral stance during World War I. Following his speech, the convention delegates voted to hold the convention in Minneapolis instead, while Chicago, which had been the unanimous selection of site selection committee, finished third.^[5]

After the caucus, Herbert served as acting state commander. He organized the Legion's first state convention and reviewed applications of new posts.^[4] After announcing his candidacy for Lieutenant Governor of Massachusetts on August 5, 1919, he submitted his resignation to the state's executive committee, but it was declined, as they believed his departure during the formative days of the Legion would harm the group and did not think he would be involved in any serious political activity until after officers who could take over his duties were elected at the first state convention. Both Herbert and the committee believed that statewide candidates for political office should not serve as state officers in the American Legion, so he declined to run for state commander.^[6] On October 16, 1919, Edward Lawrence Logan was elected commander at the first state convention.^[7]

Herbert was the Massachusetts delegation's choice for National Commander at the 1920 national convention.^[8] He received 233 votes on the first ballot, which put him in third place behind Frederick W. Galbraith and Hanford MacNider. After losing votes to Galbraith on the second ballot, Herbert and MacNider withdrew and called for Galbraith's unanimous election.^[9][10] In 1924, it was reported that Herbert was being considered for National Commander by a joint caucus of 22 states.^[11] The caucus chose to vote for James A. Drain, who was elected on the first ballot.^[12]

On August 5, 1919, the Massachusetts Democratic state committee selected Herbert as its candidate for Lieutenant Governor. It was believed that Herbert would bring the veteran vote to the Democratic ticket.^[13] Herbert won the Democratic primary unopposed. The Democratic ticket was swept in that year's state elections. Herbert lost to Republican incumbent Channing H. Cox 298,010 votes to 188,127.^[14]