John R. Roden

Meade McClanahan

Ernest E. Debs

Roden's political career started after the recall of councilman McClanahan (left) in 1946 and ended after his defeat by Debs (right) in 1947.

In 1946, Meade McClanahan, a Los Angeles City Councilman representing the 13th district, who had been elected the previous year to complete the term of Ned R. Healy after Healy was elected to the U.S. House of Representatives, faced a recall campaign that came from his association with Gerald L. K. Smith, a controversial far-right demagogue.^[4] Roden stated that he had been only casually interested in politics when he enlisted in the Army, but after attending the meeting where both Smith and McClanahan spoke he was displeased by their remarks.^[5]

In January 1946, petitions calling for McClanahan's recall were submitted to the Los Angeles City Clerk. After verification, the clerk certified the petitions and scheduled the recall election for March 19, 1946. Roden was one of five candidates who filed nomination papers for the recall election, but only three qualified. He received the endorsement of the recall coalition and was presented as a candidate whose image contrasted with McClanahan's allegation that the recall was driven by Communists.^[6] The recall succeeded, with Roden winning a landslide majority over McClanahan and succeeding him on the Los Angeles City Council.^[7]

Roden was sworn in as a councilman on March 25, 1946, he was greeted at a tour by Mayor of Los Angeles Fletcher Bowron and other city officials.^[8] He was the youngest member of the City Council and the first World War II veteran elected to a Los Angeles public office.

During his tenure, Roden attracted controversy for several decisions. In October 1946, he caused public opposition by voting in favor of constructing a city incinerator in Lincoln Heights.^[9] The following month, he was the sole council member to oppose a $1,000 reward offer related to violence during a November 1946 strike by Columbia Studios film technicians. Later that year, as the strike continued, a Roden resolution calling for arbitration drew criticism from fellow councilman Ed J. Davenport of the 12th district, who accused him of showing bias in the matter.^[10] Their feud persisted the next year when Davenport introduced a resolution requesting that the council be kept informed about the progress of various bills before the Congressional Committee on Un-American Activities, prompting a public dispute between the two councilmen over the measure.^[11]

In the 1947 election, Roden faced three challengers, including Meade McClanahan, who sought to regain his seat, and Ernest E. Debs, a California State Assemblyman and former ally of the recall movement.^[1][12] Roden and Debs advanced to the runoff election, in which Roden was ultimately defeated by Debs. Roden's support for the proposed incinerator was a significant factor in his loss, as Debs and numerous local associations campaigned against the project.^[13]

After leaving the City Council in 1947, Roden worked as a television-manufacturing executive and later sold volumes of Encyclopædia Britannica.^[14][15] He attempted to run for the California State Assembly from the 56th district, a seat vacated by Ernest E. Debs after Debs defeated Roden, but was removed from the ballot by Superior Judge Frank G. Swain after filing his affidavit of candidacy shortly before midnight on September 30 instead of meeting the 5:00 p.m. filing deadline.^[16][17]

Roden lived in the Los Angeles neighborhood of Silver Lake. He moved there with his mother as a child and continued to reside in the neighborhood during his service on the City Council.^[2] He was a Democrat.^[18]

In May 1946, Roden announced that he would be marrying Francesca Nadine Romoli, a wine heiress, marrying her on September 28, 1946 at Our Mother of Good Counsel church.^[19][20] In January 1952, Romoli and Roden divorced, previously obtaining an interlocutory decree of divorce in July 1949, reconciled six months later, and separated again in February 1950.^[14] In a testimony against him, Romoli alleged that Roden had spanked her after having political disagreements.^[21][22]

On November 19, 1953, he married Carmen Alicia Olson, who served as director of home economics for Admiral Distributors' Northern California division, now both residing in San Francisco.^[23] Roden died on January 28, 2008 at his home in Hayward, California.^[24]

Works cited

• Sitton, Tom (August 1988). "Direct Democracy vs. Free Speech: Gerald L. K. Smith and the Recall Election of 1946 in Los Angeles". Pacific Historical Review. Vol. 57. University of California Press. p. 285–304. eISSN 1533-8584. ISSN 0030-8684.