Katelin Talbert

Fimleikafélag Hafnarfjarðar

In March 2021, Talbert signed with her first professional club, FHingar, the women's football department of the Fimleikafélag Hafnarfjarðar multi-sport club.^{[citation needed]} The team finished the season 11–3–4 with Talbert recording 46 saves in goal.^[7] After playing for FHingar, Talbert trained with the West Ham United women in London from September to December 2021.^{[citation needed]}

Benfica

In January 2022, Talbert joined Sport Lisboa e Benfica, commonly known as Benfica, a Portuguese women's football team based in Lisbon that plays in the Campeonato Nacional Feminino. In her year and a half at Benfica, she played in 23 matches and won two Campeonato Nacional Feminino^{[citation needed][unreliable source]} titles, the League Cup (Taça da Liga Feminina),^{[citation needed][unreliable source]} and the Portuguese Super Cup (Supertaça de Portugal Feminina).^{[citation needed][unreliable source][8]} Talbert was elected by the Players Union as the best goalkeeper of the 2021–22 Liga BPI.^[9] Her contract ended with Sport Lisboa e Benfica, on June 30, 2023.^{[citation needed]}

West Ham United

In August 2023, Talbert signed with West Ham United Women Football Club, an English women's football club affiliated with West Ham United.^[10] The club plays in the Women's Super League, the top tier of English women's football. Talbert was immediately sent out on loan to Swedish side Djurgårdens IF in a bid to accumulate the points needed to meet Governing Body Endorsements [GBE] requirements for the International Sportsperson visa.^[11][12] She made nine appearances for the club in the Damallsvenskan, helping The Blue Stripes to avoid an end of season relegation play-off.^[13] In June 2024, Talbert was transferred back to West Ham United.^{[citation needed]}

She was loaned out to Aston Villa in January 2025 and made her debut as a second-half substitute for Sabrina D'Angelo on March 2, 2025, during a 2–0 loss against Everton at Villa Park.^[14]

Calgary Wild FC

In January 2026, she signed with Canadian Northern Super League club Calgary Wild FC, with Talbert saying of the move “The opportunity to be part of a new professional league in Canada and contribute to building a strong, competitive team really aligns with my love for growth, competition, and inspiring the next generation of women in soccer.”^[15][6]

Club

As of match played March 3, 2025^{[16][citation needed]}